I don't know enough about old plugs ...they picked them up in a yard sale for a buck. What were they? I figured you guys would know.

Sylvester Flaptail
Pond Atom (rewired as a reverse)
Heddon Vamp
? Paw Paw Pikie (not sure)
Rapala

Yup you hit the nails on the head.There are 4 others like the Sylvester. You can go to Antique saltwater lures and look through some of whats listed and it shows them.