have you ever used bluegill for striper bait?:fishin::fishin:

yup

keep em alive and 3 way em like a porgy

don't stay alive long but if there's fish they don't have to.

i've chunked them too, didn't do much that way, alive seems best

Last year we had a big threadfin shad die off and I have heard that most of the guides are either using Black Salties or Bream for bait... Thanks a bunch Vic

Vic - do you work for Black Salties? That's all you seem to talk about?

don't know about MA or RI, but in alot of states they are considered gamefish and therefore are illegal to use for bait.

No Not yet Skippy, I'm just asking for input sorry you are bored with it

I call dibs on the kixor!
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

who's Skippy? :huh:

I think he was referring to JohnR as Skippy

Bluegills are gamefish, striped bass are not? Go figure.

I think I am Skippy.

You do seem to bring them B.S. up an awful lot so you either work for them or are really confused on whether or not to use them.

If its the former and you work for them, unsolicited spam ist verbotten here. While we highly encourage open and honest debate, we don't like people taking advantage of that freedom for commercial benefit. And if you work for them you are also likely in a position contrary to the Acceptable Use Policies of the information systems where you officially work. Yes, I know where you are connecting from, Sir.

If it is the latter and you genuinely are not sure, based on where you work, I highly recommend you use some of the initiative of the people you support, yell "Charge", seize the initiative and go swim some live baits :tooth: . Then let us know how they work - product name non descriptive of course. In short, go nail a monster.

I'd love to see some (non spam) monster sweetwater striper photos. Really. And I'm only going to be 100 miles or so away next weekend visiting some of my fellow brats. Wish I had the opportunity to try but I won't as I will be conducting an extended beer quality evaluation.

I work for the Army and have for 34 years. In Ala "freaking Bama" both Bream and BS are legal for bait. I just ask a simple question, which was only my 4th post on this forum. I guess I was being a forum hoggy. If you don't like the question or the reply don't put your 2 in "Porgies Forever"

WOW

I work for the Army and have for 34 years. In Ala "freaking Bama" both Bream and BS are legal for bait. I just ask a simple question, which was only my 4th post on this forum. I guess I was being a forum hoggy. If you don't like the question or the reply don't put your 2 in "Porgies Forever"

Yep & no problem. My point is Go Use Them, Go Large (as in LARGE fish). 5 of your 7 posts are asking about B.S. which fortunately or unfortunately we can't use and has been stated several times. We have other stuff to live-line (like mackerel :drool: ) when we can get them.

So pleeeeeeeze lets talk fishing and leave the Black Salties out of it. Its not something 95% of us here can use nor recommend. Unfortunately, not much most of us can do with them.

Now, if you want to try an experiment, we need to send you a dozen Amercian Eels :btu:

THAT will kick some a$$ I bet.



Seriously, thumbs up for what you do.

Just to clarify Iamskippy!

:jump1:

Army guys don't feesh, the marines fish

Army guys don't feesh, the marines fish


The Air Force gals get their fish catered at the 19th hole :devil2:

Air Force , bah, they just fly taxi's and the Navy just drives them

http://usmcshop.grunt.com/prodimg/BS74.jpg

Army guys don't feesh, the marines fish

The redneck hick, Gomer Pyle is from Alabama.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

The redneck hick, Gomer Pyle is from Alabama.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Funny, he never left boot

Funny, he never left boot

Interesting point. I never thought of that.

In regard to the Black Salties, we got some quite a few years ago. Probably 2002 was the first year there was a lot of publicity about them here in RI.

I can't remember if they were declared illegal in RI but I do remember that we livelined some at the Great Island Bridge. Clammer, you remember? You and Billy went one afternoon and were raising 20# bass in broad daylight.
I remember my old surf partner, RJ, and I fished them one night at Black Point. Never got a fish until we switched over to eels and them we "smoked 'em". I seem to remember that they were expensive, maybe $1.50 each.

Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

The redneck hick, Gomer Pyle is from Alabama.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device


So were Hank Aaron, Bart Star, Eugene Sledge and who knows who else ;)