View Full Version : Wetsuit Reviews


chefchris401
10-28-2011, 10:04 AM
So I had a guy ask some questions via PM about what I use for a wetsuiting and after sending him a long email, I figured I would elaborate a little more on each suit and share with the general public.

Just so everyone knows, I have no agenda here, I don’t work for any of these companies or a dive shop, just my honest opinions on wetsuits that I’ve used in the surf for the past few years. Hope it helps someone out there.

My first suit ever was a 3mm NRS grizzly farmer John, it's the basic farmer John just cut for us bigger guys. I bought with Chris Chobot’s recommendation and based on his experiences with the suit. It's a great suit, cheap and comfy. MSRP is $135.00 Its has thick padded knee pads and some shin protection. Easy to get in and out of. Keeps you warm in the late spring, great summer suit and well into the fall before it gets too cold. . The thing I don't like about is the material is rough on the inside seams, gives you chub rub between the legs if you have a long walk. I go commando under the suit, some guys use a pair of under armor shorts so that might help. That’s really my only complaint about it. I used that suit hard for two seasons and still have it, shows little if any wear. It’s the suit that allowed me to make the jump from waders to wetsuiting and I’m glad I did.

Here is what their website says about the suit:

Big folks know finding the right size in boating gear can be a bear. Designed for the "teddy bear" in your group, the NRS Grizzly wetsuit is extra roomy.
• Our Grizzly™ Wetsuit features 3-mm Neoprene for superior insulation.
• Cut large around the chest, waist, thighs and calves to fit even the biggest paddle sports enthusiast.
• This suit combines the convenience of a full-length front zipper with roomy, over-the-shoulder Farmer Bill-style suspenders.

The next suit I own and use is the Neosport Xspan 3mm full suit, In my opinion the best suit you can buy for the money, super comfy like wearing nothing at all. Can walk miles in it and have no rubbing chaffing issues. MSRP is $155 but I think I got mine for $140. It's a great suit from late spring to early fall. One drawback is no high wear protection anywhere in the suit so you feel the rocks more if you go down or get pushed into them while wading out. I've popped a few stitches here and there too, but nothing a little neoprene sealer doesn’t fix. The suit stretches 250 times each way so it fits great. A great value and really comfortable suit to wear.

Here is what their website says about the suit:

Rubber: Exclusive XSPAN material – Ultra Soft and Comfortable – 250% 4-Way Super Stretch foam neoprene.
Fabric Laminate: Each suit is constructed of 100% XSPAN material, unlike other suits which only offer stretch panels or filler gussets.
Construction: All 3/2mm jumpsuits are constructed using our bomb proof flatlock stitching for comfort.
Knee Pads: Multi layer, thermal bonded knee pads are perfect for long lasting durability, maximum flexibility and attractive styling.
Additional Features: All Jumpsuits feature reliable and proven #10 YKK zippers, Adjustable Collars, Rolled Edges, Zipper Flap and Anatomical Fit arms and legs.


My best suit without question is my new Henderson Aqua-loc suit, it’s a 5mm full suit. It's also the most expensive suit I own, MSRP is $439, but I got mine on sale from the shop I buy all my wetsuits from for $330. It's a 5mm that has the warmth of a 7mm or even a 9mm. All the seams are sealed inside and outside. Has a fleece micro fiber lining which feels great on your skin!! The suit has the same stretch as the Neosport Xspan but better. I've been wearing it since the temps have been dropping and don't even notice the water. It's considered a semi dry suit do to it's construction, you literally have to pull the neck down to let water in if your too hot. In my opinion it's a great early spring, fall and into very late fall suit.

Here is what their website says about the suit:

The Aqua Loc® System begins with the core jumpsuit. One of the most notable visual feature on the suit is the Liquid tape Aqua Loc® seams. Every seam on the suits is
first double glued and blind stitched inside and out. Then the outer seam is coated with a special waterproof AquaLoc® liquid tape barrier which seals the seam from water entry and also helps protect the stitching from damage and unraveling.
The 5mm and 7mm core jumpsuits offer special Aqua Loc® wrist and ankle cuffs which have been designed to mate with specially designed Aqua Loc® Boots, Gloves and
Hood. The Aqua Loc® cuffs feature a soft and ultra stretchy Skin neoprene inner lining which mates to specially designed silicone seals inside the boots and gloves. (see
Boot and Glove detail below) 3mm Suits also mate with Aqua Loc® accessories but the double locking wrist and ankles have been removed since they are not required
in warmer water temps where 3mm suits are commonly
utilized. The interior of all the core jumpsuits are lined with a Golden micro fleece lining which dries quickly and feels luxurious against the skin. The Aqua Loc® suit exterior
features Henderson’s renowned Aquasilk laminate which is also utilized in Henderson’s flagship H2 wetsuit series. Rear zipper entry assures easy use while the PK G-lock
water resistant zipper eliminates unpleasant cold water exchange in the spine and lumbar area. Soft, flexibleand extremely durable Duratex knee pads complete the package.


My last suit is a Bare 7mm Farmer John, it's a nice early season late fall suit. The main drawback is you feel the stay puff marshmallow man in it, the material is so thick and really limits your mobility. Has the high wear knee pads and shin areas. I got it for short money as a close out and used it for 2 years early season and late fall. I wouldn't recommend buying a 7mm unless it was Neosport Xspan or Aqua-Loc. It’s a decent suit but its so cumbersome to wear the suit that I never use anymore.


I wear an under armor t shirt under my farmer John suits, adds a little warmth to your upper body and helps with chaffing.

In the summer I always, literally always wear a NRS splash top jacket over my wetsuits. A few reasons for doing so, one is my jacket is orange/yellow so I like the added visibility in case someone is approaching the spot I’m already fishing or there's people on shore just to let people now I'm there. Another reason is it cuts the wind chill down, even in the summer you'll find you get a chill if the wind is really wiping or there's a lot of spray. Last it adds some warmth. It doesn't get in the way of swimming or add any resistance.

For the cooler and winder and Nor Easter weather days I wear a dry top over the wet suit, I have a Precision Pak Pluto jacket which is awesome. Again bright orange!! It keeps you really warm just like fishing in waders but can still get out to those far spots.

I also have a 3mm NRS wetsuit jacket, basically it's a zip up jacket you can wear over any wetsuit, so takes your farmer John from a 3mm on your core to a 6mm and gives you 3mm on your arms. It's a great piece of gear to own. Really helps extend your season and keeps you really warm, also might stop you from having to buy another suit. Think the jacket was around $100. The only drawback is the arms are cut weird, you get use to it but there too long and the body seems too short. Then over that I'll wear my splash top.

Well I hope that helps anyone who might be considering making the switch from waders to wetsuits.

I’m sure some of the other guys on the site will chime in about what they wear and their findings.

Sea Dangles
10-28-2011, 10:23 AM
This post makes me grateful for my boat. Flipflops and shorts never sounded better.

JohnR
10-28-2011, 11:17 AM
What is your feeling on the buoyancy of each? The rule of thumb being the thicker the suit the better it floats?

chefchris401
10-28-2011, 12:18 PM
What is your feeling on the buoyancy of each? The rule of thumb being the thicker the suit the better it floats?

well being a fat guy i float pretty well anyway.

but the thicker the suit the more float it has, and also the better the seal and fit the more buoyancy its going to add.

In the 3mm your legs will natural float up, it adds a lot of float but the 5mm or 7mm has a lot more overall. youll float like a cork in a 5 or 7mm.

Ive always felt that it would hard to drown in a 3mm wetsuit unless you were knocked out or got caught in some rope or something. Really helps when your bobbing around to distance rocksto have that extra float makes climbing and getting up the rocks that much easier.

WackinEm
10-28-2011, 01:35 PM
i have a 5mm neosport xpan, love the suit, barely know youre wearing it. for the colder months i have a 3mm hooded neosport xspan vest to put under the suit and a dry top over it to cut the wind.

as far as floating around, it keeps my head above water when i'm floating in a sitting position, but at 5'11 175, i dont have a lot of natural flotation, add to that the gear hanging off of my belt and i can see why i'm not floating any higher. with the vest on, my shoulders clear the water when im in a sitting position

Liv2Fish
10-30-2011, 08:42 AM
I fish Cape Cod Bay primarily and will be switching to wetsuit for next year. Before the kids arrived, I used to spend more time underwater than above so I have a nice Henderson superstreatch 7MM suit.

What's the water temp range for 3, 5 and 7mm. I'm assuming air temp has a lot to do with it too. I remember being so hot I was ready to puke, standing on the deck of the boat waiting for someone else to finish gearing up. I couldn't wait to get in the 60 degree water.

We always made it a point to dive on the first week in April. The water was typically 40 to 44 degrees and I could handle about an hour in that range in a 7 mill. It seemed like a week went by before I could actually feel my feet again but the core temp would be manageable.

I know I'll need to buy another suit but I'm not sure if I should go with 3mm or 5mm. Maybe fish the 7mm in the spring and fall and the other in mid season.

luds
10-30-2011, 11:31 AM
Surprised to see you guys like you neosport suits. I have the vest that I wear over my henderson when its really cold andd its great for that but the material shows wear and is very pilly like a crappy t shirt. I would not want that directly on my skin.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

chefchris401
10-30-2011, 03:07 PM
It's the neosport xspan I like, which is completely different material than the regular suits.

Mine is silky smooth inside and out.

Just wish it had some extra padding in the knee and shin areas.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

bassballer
10-31-2011, 10:30 AM
This post makes me grateful for my boat. Flipflops and shorts never sounded better.

I have to admit. When I bought my boat I kept saying that I would never stop surf fishing. I could never give up that feeling of swimming out to my rocks in solitude, the surf is theraputic, the feelin of battling a fish while taking waves in the chest, blah blah. Ive been surf fishing once since I bought the boat in early august.

piemma
11-01-2011, 03:50 PM
I have to admit. When I bought my boat I kept saying that I would never stop surf fishing. I could never give up that feeling of swimming out to my rocks in solitude, the surf is theraputic, the feelin of battling a fish while taking waves in the chest, blah blah. Ive been surf fishing once since I bought the boat in early august.

I bought the boat when I got diagnosed with cancer. I couldn't hop rocks anymore due to the Chemo and radiation treatments.
Now it's 6 years. The cancer goes away for a couple of years and then re-occurs but I am back in the surf, at least in the Fall. I won't let them do chemo anymore. Didn't work the first time so I don't think it will work now. All I know is I still love the feel of waves hitting me.

GattaFish
11-01-2011, 07:10 PM
What is your feeling on the buoyancy of each? The rule of thumb being the thicker the suit the better it floats?


I don't care what anyone says,,, nothing less than 5 mil for me. the buoyancy is key and the warmth is important too,,,

I had some squirly water pull me down and hold me under in June was not fun and I am a good swimmer. I wear a 5 mil. No way I would chance a 3 mil to float me around. I rather deal with jumping in to cool off.

Hate to say it you could drown VERY easily in a wetsuit.

As far as warmth. Even if the air is blistering hot I still get the 4 am chill. I regularly fish all night and being in the water for long periods of time drains the heat from your body.

It is easy to cool off and actually refreshing to let a little water in. Definitely not easy to warm up.


The key to any wetsuit is that it fits you properly and does not bunch up and chafe. The new stretchy neoprene is the way to go.