View Full Version : Economics of plowing


nightfighter
10-30-2011, 08:57 AM
Tossing around the idea of picking up a small plow and an older pick up to do a few driveways locally. Any input? Have some road and parking lot plowing experience years ago, but was someone else's equipment. Always dependent on how many storms and breakdown/maintenance costs. Last winter was slow for work, but am I crazy to even consider this? Or is it just blood money I'm looking at?Pretty sure I could get a dozen driveways minimum. Would want to keep initial investment under 5k. Would consider unloading it in spring. Already have an Ariens snowblower my driveway is small.

Pete F.
10-30-2011, 10:13 AM
If you don't need one for your driveway and don't want a 4wd don't bother with the investment. If you have a 4wd, time and need to plow your own drive then it might make sense. Otherwise I think you need to be all in or out.

Slingah
10-30-2011, 10:37 AM
don't forget liability issues and insurance cost...
my thought is that 5k is not going to get you anything but a old headache of a rig.....
I have thrown this idea around for years....never could justify the expense or effort.

Karl F
10-30-2011, 10:59 AM
a decent new plow runs around 5 grand, 2500 for a decent secondhand.. a decent 3/4 ton or one ton 4X4, used, well...crapshoot.. if you buy one that's plowed before.. you have already thrown a seven.

transmission shops love guys that plow... always keep that in mind, especially guys that keep it in 4 high range and power the chit out of it. tranny and transfer case work escalates immensely for these shops once we are into snow season.

keep the 5 K in the bank, keep the blower running and the shovel sharp, buy bonds with the money you save.

Karl F
10-30-2011, 11:00 AM
don't forget liability issues and insurance cost...
my thought is that 5k is not going to get you anything but a old headache of a rig.....
I have thrown this idea around for years....never could justify the expense or effort.

Bingo

niko
10-30-2011, 11:02 AM
the problem with doing it w/ an old truck is maintenance on the equipment. plowing beats on trucks - i have a 8 yr old f250 that is on the verge of needing to be replaced. if you can do your own repair work than an older truck may be an option but what are you going to do when it breaks down in the middle of a storm. customers don't want to be inconvienenced at all in this day and age, they will start calling and bitching. that being said - plowing is a great additional income when it is slow in the winter. thank god for snow - like little white dollar signs falling from the sky

Nebe
10-30-2011, 11:03 AM
Pennies from heaven.. Not $100 bills is what my dad says.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

OLD GOAT
10-30-2011, 11:17 AM
To embarrassed to tell you how long I've done it.
Iwould suggest just doing a dozen neighbors on your street with the snow blower and put --all--the money in the bank.

If yer buying 2nd hand,,do I have a deal fer yoo.All kinds of junk fer sale

Karl F
10-30-2011, 11:21 AM
forgot to mention, if you do buy a truck, make sure it came with factory snow plow prep package, had a tech explain to me in detail the importance of that, as if the truck did not come with all that is in the prep package, suspension, drivetrain wise, etc. it will become an issue as soon as you overtask the truck.
I was truck shopping earlier this year..not impressed with ANY of the new ones, but you can build a decent one, if you choose wisely off the order sheet. Fortunately, I lucked out, and got a clean 10 year old truck with very low miles, that will do what I want it to, and the best part is, I didn't have to get another payment book..took me 3 months of looking though.

OLD GOAT
10-30-2011, 11:23 AM
To embarrassed to tell you how long I've done it.
Iwould suggest just doing a dozen neighbors on your street with the snow blower and put --all--the money in the bank.

If yer buying 2nd hand,,do I have a deal fer yoo.All kinds of junk fer sale

Karl F
10-30-2011, 11:24 AM
To embarrassed to tell you how long I've done it.
Iwould suggest just doing a dozen neighbors on your street with the snow blower and put --all--the money in the bank.

If yer buying 2nd hand,,do I have a deal fer yoo.All kinds of junk fer sale

You Sir, would know!.. .Nice to put a face to that name, and you look nothing like a goat... capesams is still older than you tho, I would venture! least he looks it! :uhuh:

Sea Dangles
10-30-2011, 11:33 AM
I have an 02 suburban Z71 that will be on the market soon. 158k and oil changed religiously. Shows like new. Good rubber too.
That being said, nothing is more true than the blood money part. Driveways are good,but if you are subbing for a town or state it can get personal.Read some of Fisherman Tim's posts from last winter for examples of an assache.

niko
10-30-2011, 11:40 AM
you guys make it sound like staying up for 36 hrs straight and drinking so much coffee that you're twitching isn't fun

Karl F
10-30-2011, 11:55 AM
did 76 hours in a 1962 GMC 6 wheel dump truck, blizzard of 78, last man standing, town of Brewster, biggest POS ever, Highway supervisor figgered i be the first broke down, he pulls me over on Lower Road 3 days later, to tell me at that point, I am the only one still mobile... no brakes, no clutch, no lights for the most part, but still rolling... manual pump on the plow, and NO power angle.. fun... NOT.. only time you know you nodded off was when the headache went away, for a few seconds, can't figure out dawn from dusk, nor how many days have past.. well.. it does resemble hard core surfcasting at that point.

OLD GOAT
10-30-2011, 12:42 PM
For a minute I thought you meant the blizzard of 58.
Don't cha love siting in your sweat on a plastic seat while your feet are freezing and you have to open the door every ten minutes to clear the wiper arms from the snow pileup. Don't forget trying to backup with one of those four inch round lollipop mirrors that were before the west coast mirrors.
All that for five bucks an hour. That's truck,fuel,and driver.
Yup .what a killing. The things you do to feed your babies

Karl F
10-30-2011, 01:56 PM
:D You know it O.G.!

Swimmer
10-30-2011, 02:11 PM
A guy that used to be on our aux. police force always plowed. Always had an F-150 or 250. Always bragged about how he made 25 K every winter. Its funny how he had to spend 10 or 12 K every spring in the repair shop, ( I know I watched as the repairs were done), so he could tow his fifth wheel down to Pocasett. Three year old trucks so rusted underneath you think it lived on Chappy all year round.

Karl F
10-30-2011, 06:57 PM
1991 Ford F250 8' Plow 79071 miles, (http://boston.craigslist.org/nos/ctd/2654015726.html)

that is prolly as good as 5grand is gonna get you.

gf2020
10-30-2011, 07:03 PM
Plowing in Marblehead is a pain. Driveways and yards are small; no place to put the snow. For residential work you would want a Jeep or a regular cab Ford Ranger or Toyota Tacoma. Tough to find a decent one with a plow for under $5K.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Karl F
10-30-2011, 07:17 PM
Plowing in Marblehead is a pain. Driveways and yards are small; no place to put the snow. For residential work you would want a Jeep or a regular cab Ford Ranger or Toyota Tacoma. Tough to find a decent one with a plow for under $5K.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Snow Is Here - 93 Jeep Cherokee Plow Truck (http://boston.craigslist.org/gbs/cto/2670923310.html)

you wanna go light duty, this has potential, plow early and often, a 3/4 ton can handle up to say 14-16 inches of average snow, lighter vehicles, start removal at 3-4 inches, and keep going back, remember tho, light duty, so go easy, and most likely more repairs.. the blower will do the job, and cost you less in the long run.

justplugit
10-31-2011, 07:55 AM
did 76 hours in a 1962 GMC 6 wheel dump truck, blizzard of 78, last man standing, town of Brewster, biggest POS ever, Highway supervisor figgered i be the first broke down, he pulls me over on Lower Road 3 days later, to tell me at that point, I am the only one still mobile... no brakes, no clutch, no lights for the most part, but still rolling... manual pump on the plow, and NO power angle.. fun... NOT.. only time you know you nodded off was when the headache went away, for a few seconds, can't figure out dawn from dusk, nor how many days have past.. well.. it does resemble hard core surfcasting at that point.

So Karl, did the air conditioner hold up? :huh: LOL

Gary
11-01-2011, 06:57 PM
What I used to do and make a bit was the exits off the midcape, 2wd F350 6 wheeler, 4 years, 1 set of kingpins and 3 C6 auto trans's. Went to a handshaker and got 2 seasons out of it then realised it wasn't worth it timewise. Didn't get the job done fast but it got it done and did pull quite a few landscapers in newer 4x4 trucks out of snowbanks......
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Karl F
11-01-2011, 08:07 PM
almost a tranny a year, and C6's are damn tough...I've heard the on and off ramps are a good gig... a 2WD 6 wheel dump with a sander in the back is usually a damn good set up, rear diff is usually not an open set up, so you do get the posi benifit.. kingpins...yep, front ends take a pounding for sure.

Karl F
11-01-2011, 08:07 PM
So Ross.. what you decide???

nightfighter
11-01-2011, 08:23 PM
Best option for me is to keep the 1973 Ariens happy... Keep my focus on generating the work I do, remodeling/finish carpentry. The few trucks I've looked at were beat, overpriced, or needed work from the get go. I'm far from a mechanic, so between the maintenance and the fear of breaking down during a storm and leaving clients in the lurch has pretty much sealed the deal. Unless I meet a little old lady with a sweetheart truck and plow that she only drove to church....nah, that's not gonna happen. Just had to run through the process.

Karl F
11-01-2011, 09:00 PM
:btu:

Raider Ronnie
11-01-2011, 09:01 PM
Ross,
November is the time to find a deal on a lawn mower or tractor. :uhuh:
When time to replace or upgrade my trucks I look and find deals after the winter is over, lots of guys looking to unload them then.
Also, if you have an in at auctions (as I do) thats where you find the deals.
I usually buy a truck with no plow. Got a few plows that have been on 4 different trucks as I replaced them.

Rockfish9
11-03-2011, 10:23 AM
been that route... save yourself the trouble.. at one time I had 4 trucks on the town and did driveways with my private vehicle... unless you have a in home welding shop and are a mechanic with enough of a bank roll to sit on reapairs for awhile forget it .. just use the snow blower... people tend ( especialy companies) to drag out paying the snow plow guy.. also everyone wants to be first and last.... I had some people that never did pay me after the "blizzard" of '78.. and quite a few since then until I gave it up.. they just move on to the next victim that thinks they are going to get rich with a snow plow...knowing that the average working man ( trying to make an honest living) doesnt have time to go to court..

PaulS
11-03-2011, 02:09 PM
So Ross.. what you decide???

I was reading the thread and going to post the exact same question:).

tattoobob
11-03-2011, 06:24 PM
Best option for me is to keep the 1973 Ariens happy... Keep my focus on generating the work I do, remodeling/finish carpentry. The few trucks I've looked at were beat, overpriced, or needed work from the get go. I'm far from a mechanic, so between the maintenance and the fear of breaking down during a storm and leaving clients in the lurch has pretty much sealed the deal. Unless I meet a little old lady with a sweetheart truck and plow that she only drove to church....nah, that's not gonna happen. Just had to run through the process.

Great Idea Ross, We have a F-350 that came with a plow
I hate plowing and would rather shovel than fire that plow truck up
Driving the truck on the Beach with a 300 pound camper on it beats on my wife's truck enough

piemma
11-04-2011, 05:54 AM
Plowing is a no win situation. I did it for years with an F250 4X4. Front end work, tranny, drive shaft (both of them). Broken cutting edge on plow. Blown hydralic lines, and the list goes on and on.

I now have a guy plow my driveway. 800 feet long, a turn around and parking area for 6 cars. Charges me 40 to 50 bucks depending on how much snow. 10 big storms a winter and I spend $500. You can't even get a set of new truck tires for that money.

niko
11-04-2011, 06:28 AM
I'm surprised at how much negativity there is about plowing. It's pretty good to me
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

nightfighter
11-04-2011, 06:51 AM
Niko,
No doubt it could be good. But I'm looking at the cost of entry, as I don't currently have a plow truck, nevermind a plow. Already have had a year of significant car repair/maintenance bills with my 2000 Tahoe and better half's car. Still have payments on my 2003 Express work truck. In this economy, and the twins having just entered college, I can't justify taking on more debt given the abuse that plowing would put on an asset I am just starting to pay down.
And on that note, I am off to work. Rebuild a bulkhead today.

niko
11-04-2011, 08:01 AM
I get it doesn't fit your situation ross, just surprised no one else had anything positive to say about it
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Rockfish9
11-04-2011, 08:42 AM
I get it doesn't fit your situation ross, just surprised no one else had anything positive to say about it
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

I think what is trying to be conveyed ( maybe not sucessfully in my case) is that it is not the golden goose some people make it out to be...it's like any buisness adventure... there are up sides and down sides.. for people with seasonal buisness.. it is a way to pay the bills when there is no cash flow.. land scapers bring the perfect scenario... they are used to maintaining their own equipment and have the time to repair and maintian between storms... they also usualy have an established clientel... but for someone to go out, buy a truck and find new customers is taking a big risk... especialy since those dependable customers already have a chosen plow company... the ones ( obviously not all) looking for some one in a pinch may not be all that reliable... i plowed snow for over 20 years.. and in the end i made money... it wasn't fun... it was hard work.. i even lost money some seasons.. some season I made enough to up grade equipment... as i said earlier.. it's just a buisness adventure.. not a get rich scheme.. not that Ross was looking for that.. i understand he was looking for a suppliment....he asked for advise.. I'm giving an honest answer... from someone that has more than a season or two of experience...

fishsmith
11-17-2011, 11:31 AM
F350 at auction this weekend @ Mass Maritme

http://www.maritime.edu/apps/boats/admin/images/P6220012.JPG

full list, lots of stuff looks way overpriced, but I don't know if the prices shown are starting bids

http://www.maritime.edu/apps/boats/index.cfm?sort=price

tattoobob
11-17-2011, 06:16 PM
$5800 for a 96 Ford F350 is way to much

Karl F
11-17-2011, 06:22 PM
I would not want to plow driveways with that beast either, full 4 door dually crew cab with an 8 foot bed, need a football field to turn it around.

fishsmith
11-18-2011, 06:36 PM
I would not want to plow driveways with that beast either, full 4 door dually crew cab with an 8 foot bed, need a football field to turn it around.

:smash: hmmmm, I didn't think of that. Oh well, another good reason why I snowblow and shovel :tooth:

nightfighter
11-30-2014, 08:01 PM
A guy I trust picked up a 2000 Dodge Dakota Sport, with a 6' MM Fisher plow. Asking 2k He has gone through it for brakes and basics. I still have a few questions for him but may offer him a lower number this week. He got it off a kid who got a DUI and couldn't make his payments. Small enough to turn around in driveways and Old Town too.

niko
11-30-2014, 08:40 PM
fine for small storms but when we get a big one you and your customers are gonna be bummed out. if its just for personal use it will be fine as long as you keep up with the berm at the end of your driveway

trevier
11-30-2014, 09:24 PM
A guy I trust picked up a 2000 Dodge Dakota Sport, with a 6' MM Fisher plow. Asking 2k He has gone through it for brakes and basics. I still have a few questions for him but may offer him a lower number this week. He got it off a kid who got a DUI and couldn't make his payments. Small enough to turn around in driveways and Old Town too.
try plowing 8 inches of wet snow with that thing, plowing is blood money and I hate it. Been plowing since 94 if I could give it up I would.

Jackbass
12-01-2014, 09:26 AM
You can't have a heavy enough pick up to move snow IMHO. Particularly if you are using it to make money. Time is of the essence and spending 2 hours on a 40 dollar driveway is never a good deal. A Dakota may handle your personal space without issue but the transmission and front end will need to be re built every year. The 46RE tranny is notorious for failures.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Fly Rod
12-01-2014, 09:37 AM
keep the snow blower and hire someone to plow when snow is to deep....how many times around here ya need to be plowed...6 maybe at 50 bucks and no headaches of breakdowns & repairs