That's right. Eels or close casting won't usually present you with a problem as far as spool depletion. I am thinking more along the lines of a long cast with a lure in a canal type environment. On another note #^&#^&#^&#^&#^&#^&, I was reading Steve's article this month about his favorite line and you mentioned in some of your posts you also like the back country from ande. What makes the ande better than say, big game 20#? That's what I use now and am looking at back country for next year.

I turned steve on to the line and now he loves it, why? its twice as abrasion resistant than big game, it has less memory, it cast smoother, my frequency of line changes has went down because the line simply hold up better. When I used big game the abrasion from my thumb alone while casting conventional was enough to nessesitate a line change every other trip, not so with the backcountry, I have had nothing but an overall increase in reliability , castibility and fish fighting power using the ande....

i fish casting reels about 75% of the time in the surf and only abu 7000-class reels. the only maintenance i give mine is to throw away the stock drags and replace them w/ smooothies or xtreme smooothies. after one season, new drags again as they get flattened and burned out w/ a real tight drag setting plus the heat buildup from steady fish pressure. i clean my own reels and probably clean my hardest fished 7000 twice or maybe 3 times a season as salt water does find its way into the gearcase, which is my only gripe. while it's open during the pre-fall cleaning, i clean the drag again. you have to oil the bearings every couple trips to avoid that whine-sound from dry bearings. i hear that too often from 7000 owners and they typicallly are the ones complaining about distance w/ that reel. clean bearings means at least 30% longer casts, easier casts, and less backlashes. also, you must clean the levelwind gear and tracks occasionally. some say use a 7000 w/ bushings. i have one that i use and it has bushing. i can outcast that bushing'ed reel by 25% and it's far easier to cast the bearing one.

i've had my 7000s slammed by waves countless times and can go back night after night w/o cleaning anything, but maybe throwing some oil on the levewind and in the bearings. the drag works perfectly. if i know that there is a good chance i'll be wading in the surf and the reel will be underwater, then a spinning reel w/ a closed gear case is the best choice.

i've seen the "wave" of casting reels come in and out over the years. calcuttas, penns, abu's, etc. some made a big impression early, such as the abu-magged 6500s and the penn 525 mag, but after being in the hands of some top casters and fishermen i usually see the same reel return to their hands, an abu-7000. to me, that says a lot. i have yet to be inspired to change. a calcutta 400 or abu 6500-class reel does not have the drag pressure nor capacity i need. a calcutta 700, maybe, but i didn't see some of them last a long time in the surf. saltist? who knows.

who else has experience w/ their casting reels in the surf, rocks, sand, bridges, whatever. what's your favorite and why?

what are you fishing for seawolf?? My 400s have taken many 40lb+ fish in heavy structure, breachways and everything in between? The only place I can see where one may need more capacity is the canal....I have caught fish on my calcuttas with 3oz jigs in a heavy curent in the gallilie chanell...Not one problem. I used to use a 7000 for well over 10 years exclusive, In my opinion the calcutta is far better and With the calcutta I dont have to oil the bearings every other trip or soak the level wind with wd or any of that stuff. Fads come and go yes but, I dont think you can call the calcutta a "here today gone tommorow fad" these reels have earned there place in the suds !

And once again I think we have a thread getting beaten to death...I guess eveyone has there opinion and I think eveyone has a point....all the reels mentioned here have there place and purpose its a matter of taste ...I really cant say anything more on this subject exept that If you ask me what reel to get for 98% of surfcasting duties my answer is the calcutta 400.......

It's true. Reel fads happen. But some reels stand the test of time. When the Newells first came out in the 80s, most of the guys I fish the Canal with retired their Squidders and got Newells. Many still fish with their 20 year old Newells. Some tried the Penn GS 535 when they first came out, and went back to their Newells, as the Penn was heavier, sat higher on the rod, and was harder to cast. Some tried the Daiwa Sealine-X reels, and found that in addition to the weight and higher profile on the rod, the canted gearbox made gripping the rod cumbersome. I've always liked Newells for the simplicity of design and ease of maintenence. The Penn 525 Mag is a pain in the ass to work on. Even oiling the bearings requires removing 6 screws. When Carl Newell came back with the old P series, I grabbed two, a 229 and a 220, because I was told they were just going to be a limited run. Now, everyone has them and they're back to stay.

Basically, I think it depends what you came in with. If it lasts and fits your needs, you stick with it. Many of the newer Canal regulars use the 7000. They liked the levelwind to ease their transition to conventional, and they stuck with what they learned on. When I was starting to learn conventional, all of the regulars told me "levelwinds are for sissies" and "it'll never stand up to sand". Some have told me now, that if they were just starting fishing, they'd buy a levelwind ;)

My Calcutta 400 is 7 seasons old and it has a lot of battle scars on it. Scratches and chips from rocks. It's still going strong. The reels have been on the market now for around 10 years. I don't consider them a fad any longer. They outlasted the Abu Morrum, which was their main competitor at first in that price point. They're a much better reel (IMO) than the Penn 965. The 6500 is a great reel too. Different price point, different features.

all very interesting
So I guess the black big game is the only abu w/ brass side plates? I thought the chrome rocket has them as well.

Can a penn drag get wet and still function? If I were to put HT-100's in an abu would that drag work ok if it got splashed?

The Chrome Sports rocket may have the brass side plates , I'm not sure. You also have to be careful about the custom runs of reels. If you order about 500 of them and are willing to pay , ABU will make you up special models where you can put all the goodies from various models into one special reel. usually the cost is very high.

I really loved the Abu morrum when it was new. trouble was it lasted only 1 season cause the bearing rusted immediately. they have the odd ball bearings , one big one and one little one. the set costs $40 to replace!!! That was it for the Morrum. I think for fresh water it would have been nice. anyway , as Mike P said , the Calcutta lasts for year. I'm not big on the thumb bar on the Calcutta . I think it reduces access to the spool . On the ABU's the reels are wide open from the back on the levelwinds.

Anyway , in over 8 years now since I switched back to conventionals (used them as a teenager then switched to spinners. ) the only reels I've liked are the BG 6500CL , the BG 7000CL (Both old black models) the Mag elites we got from Australia from Steve barret and the Calcutta 400. All have their little advantage under certain circumstances. The BG7000Cl being the main tool for 90% of my fishing now which is at the canal where I need almost 300 yards of line.

Someone asked about why the old BG series over the mag Elite and the sports Rocket. i can't comment on the sports rocket , never owned one. Bg 6500 vs a 6500 CS Mag , the answere is the stiffness of the frame and the drag clicker vs the mag casting control. The Mag casting control slider on the mag Elites is simply in a abd place. You set the thing on about 1.5 for casting eels into the wind. The web between your thumb and forefinger will hit the slider and shove it down to zero. The reel explodes. Everyone who owns one knows this happens. I now tape the slider down with black electrical tape.

Anyway , after all the discussion , if I could have only one reel for the beach , it would be the old model BG 6500CL. For the canal , There is only one reel in my world , its the old model BG7000CL.

Others may disagree, but if you are new to conventional tackle I'd advise you to start out with something shorter than 10 feet and definitely avoid braid unless you own a tackle store. A 10 foot rod will develop spool speed that is hard to handle and backlashes with braid will result in a lost plug. If you boat fish, I'd start with a 7 foot medium action muskie rod, a standard 6500 or 400, and either 17 Lb Mono or 20 lb fireline. If you beach fish, a Lamiglas GLB108 is a nice parabolic rod that will handle plugs 1-3 oz and handle decent fish comfortably. A slower (and with graphite that's all relative) rod unloads more smoothly and will allow you to learn faster and more enjoyably. I own bigger Lamiglas, Kennedy fisher, and zziplex rods, and lots of different reels, but the little Lamiglas 108 that I built 20+ years ago with a calcutta 400 and 20lb fireline is the outfit I'd choose if I had to pick just one. One final note, when you start stick with aerodynanmic plugs and concentrate on keeping things smooth, don't try to add distance with an extra snap at the end of your stroke and if you are right handed, get a right handed reel. You will want to thumb the reel with your dominant hand.