Striper Talk Striped Bass Fishing, Surfcasting, Boating

Striper Talk Striped Bass Fishing, Surfcasting, Boating (http://www.striped-bass.com/Stripertalk/index.php)
-   StriperTalk! (http://www.striped-bass.com/Stripertalk/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   Does it make you angry that the Striper industry... (http://www.striped-bass.com/Stripertalk/showthread.php?t=61357)

big jay 01-04-2010 10:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pete_G (Post 736725)
Sounds like the book Iron Mike has been threatening to write the past few years.

It's 200 pages long. 199 are blank and on the last page there's a picture of an eel.

First thing I thought of when I started reading this thread.

Goose 01-04-2010 10:44 PM

What ever makes you happy. If a your happy casting with an upside down spinner good for you ...I don't get why so many are concerned whether or not some other guy is or isn't catchin. Would I like to catch 30 fish like CH, yup, would I like to be good at pluggin, yup, the fact is I am content doing my thing and sharing it with a few guys. All that tackle and books tv all has its purpose, not like we're all made of the same mold.

Yeah right eels will solve everything..lol, ok.

MAKAI 01-04-2010 11:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JohnR (Post 736701)
Rizzo - it's nice to get down to basics. You're single right. no kids? Enjoy it while you can. On the other hand, there is not much out there better than taking your kid fishing :btu: - Wait until you do that.

You may find it just as nice when the Son takes the Father fishing.

Mike P 01-04-2010 11:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by redlite (Post 736671)
:huh:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Slipknot (Post 736713)
I'm with you

Quote:

Originally Posted by Swimmer (Post 736756)
No.

Yeah. Someone want to wake me up when it's May? :sleeps:

rizzo 01-05-2010 07:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JohnR (Post 736701)
Rizzo - it's nice to get down to basics. You're single right. no kids? Enjoy it while you can. On the other hand, there is not much out there better than taking your kid fishing :btu: - Wait until you do that.

Hey John - its been a very long time. I actually made it through a fishing season with a steady girlfriend this year! Not married, no kids :buds: But I realize it could eventually be on the way. I think I've finally figured out the right balance...

The way I look at the kids thing, is its a chance to revisit everything I went through and get to see it from a different perspective - It will change things, but hopefully it'll have many positive changes.

rizzo 01-05-2010 07:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Krispy (Post 736722)
Exactly Rizzo :uhuh:
And it takes half a lifetime to be a good striperman, not because of ALL the intense, indepth, super secret time on the water knowledge you have to gather together, its wading through the hip deep BS of info, experts and product sales that gets your head spinning till you dont know whats right anymore.
I bet all you really, I mean REALLY, needed to know to go out and catch large could be written on one side a sheet of paper.

I agree, you go out and try everything, fish all up and down the coast, try it all. You eventually find out less is more!

I had a good convo with a buddy last night about the potential/big catches that have been made in some spots that have never been written about or aren't really known about. Most are afraid to go off on their own and discover new grounds. Most want it easy and get content with what they have and having faith that the good ol' days will come back to where they are fishing. YEARS go by and theyre left with nothing, because things are constantly changing. Its very hard work to keep up with the change from the surf - its easy to see why people keep their hard earned info so guarded.

I guess the better guys out there have learned to push aside media hype and how-to articles and build a confidence of their own. Some of the best I know have lived through the glory days, but when they look back at their catches in recent years, 2000 - 2010, the info and stories they share proves that there still are quality fish to be had in decent numbers, just a different game.

Joe 01-05-2010 08:35 AM

My son said he wanted to become competent surfcaster someday, I told him to forget it - he could become a doctor in less time.
That's what people don't realize - nowadays, the best and the brightest are not in law, medicine and finance, they're in the recreational fishing industry - that's what all the really smart people are doing these days.

MAKAI 01-05-2010 08:45 AM

I bet all you really, I mean REALLY, needed to know to go out and catch large could be written on one side a sheet of paper.[/QUOTE]



Occam's razor.

Nebe 01-05-2010 08:55 AM

Live bait in the dark near rocks and current as often as possible. Chumming helps.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Back Beach 01-05-2010 09:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CowHunter (Post 736740)
I love how many here are lost in yester-year and they dont even know what they have in front of them.....
- Give me pogies or give me eels
- Timing tide / wind
- Bite windows can last 15 minutes, .5hours, an hour, 1/4 tide, half tide, whole tide, multiple tides, slack tides, running tides
- The fish are always with or near the bait, those big bodies of fish, those that many dream of, are with sustainable bait supply
- Always go to the fish, the fish dont come to you.. Just because they were there last year, and the year before, doesnt mean they will be there now.
- Stay AWAY from the Crowds! All my biggest hits were done with not a soul in sight!
- Find your own grounds
- Pay attention to detail, the slightest things make a difference, the way you hook a bait, the weight, freshness, leader material, presentation....
- Stop chasing the reports and following others....Make your own reports - To yourself!
- Every day is a new day, learn something new...
- You cant buy experience on the bookshelves...Many want it easy - every day, they want the fish stacked. i got news for you, Gotta work for it...

This isnt yester-year, stop dreaming of then, this is now.... To many people are stuck in the past and dont change with the times, They Loose..........

John, I hear ya on the kids... I got 2- a 4 year old and a 2 year old and 2 full time jobs, fish smarter and make it count.... Ill sleep when I die...

Now, we can all be like sandman and bitch about how there are no fish...

2 hours in July of 09, 30 fish Limit

Good post Ken and I'll add this:

Time on the water trumps all of the above and makes the above possible. In other words, I've spent most of my life chasing bass from boat and shore. The times when it seemed like I had it all dialed in were simply due to fish abundance and my being out there every day to cash in.

There was very little genius involved but there was much personal sacrifice, risk, expense, and sometimes carelessness incurred in an effort to produce weight slips, pictures, and bragging rights.

Glad I got it all out in my 20's before marriage and kids as there's really nothing glorious about pursuing the sport at rabid levels. Its really quite tiring and becomes a rat race you can never seem to step away from.

The good part is the experience gleaned from these efforts gets put to good use in creating good life balance for me now.

Most of my striper heros look back with a certain level of resentment on their heydays and regret many decisions they made all in the name of killing a few more fish for their (alleged) gain.

Crafty Angler 01-05-2010 10:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe (Post 736798)

...That's what people don't realize - nowadays, the best and the brightest are not in law, medicine and finance, they're in the recreational fishing industry - that's what all the really smart people are doing these days.

Geez, Joe, I never thought of that - perhaps the MacArthur Foundation really is looking to grant one of their 'genius' Awards to a fish-head somewhere to further their studies unfettered by financial concerns...:hihi:

Boy, I called this one wrong - I'll have to admit this thread took a turn I never anticipated...:confused:

I've been thinking, maybe Krispy's anger is just the result of a personal epiphany and the pangs of passing through the looking glass into the realm of Zen. Coming to terms with the inevitable paradigm shift is never easy...:smokin:

Or maybe he's just sick of buying worthless fishing crap...:rotf2:

Pt.JudeJoe 01-05-2010 10:52 AM

pointjudelurescatchfishpointjudelurescatchfishpoin tjudelurescatchfishpointjudelurescatchfishpointjud elurescatchfishpointjudelurescatchfishpointjudelur escatchfishpointjudelurescatchfishpointjudeluresca tchfishpointjudelurescatchfishpointjudelurescatchf ishpointjudelurescatchfish

Pete_G 01-05-2010 11:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Crafty Angler (Post 736817)

I've been thinking, maybe Krispy's anger is just the result of a personal epiphany and the pangs of passing through the looking glass into the realm of Zen. Coming to terms with the inevitable paradigm shift is never easy...:smokin:

Or maybe he's just sick of buying worthless fishing crap...:rotf2:

I was going to go into a diatribe on the changing nature of the relationship between retail, wholesale, and marketing and the effect of the modern, anyone can do it marketing mentality thanks to Facebook, online forums, Twitter, easy to use video editing software and all the other tools now available which are probably the reasons everyone feels so heavily pressured all the time (not just in the fishing industry).

But I didn't really care enough and couldn't fully decipher what was actually going on in the thread so a little humor thanks to the Iron Midget seemed more appropriate.

DZ 01-05-2010 11:09 AM

Interesting thread and interesting opinions but there is so much more.

I think some try and simplify what we do which is a mistake. There is so much to learn and it’s not all about the “catching”. There are many out there that know how to catch - but just as many don’t know “why” they’re catching. I’ve been fishing the surf for about 40 years and in that time I’ve met maybe two hands worth of fishermen who IMO truly understand how to consistently take large bass from the surf – all of them had an intimate relationship with the areas they fished regularly and could easily adapt to a new location. They not only knew where and when – but they all took the time to try and uncover the reasons why.

I’ve had fishermen ask me for some guidance about where to fish in Newport or Block – I usually provide them with a baseline of locations and tides. But very few have ever asked me why this spot and why at this time? Those are the questions you need to try and answer and believe me it would take more than one page to list them. This is what I try and convey in some of my writing and seminars.

For example: Interested Surfcaster- “What is the one location I should cast when I go to Block?” DZ – “Fish the bar at SW.” Interested surfcaster – “Great, thanks!”
Follow up question that should be asked but wasn’t: Interested surfcaster – “Why the bar at SW?” DZ – “The bar at SW is a feeding station during the last three hours of the ebb. The current pulls hard right to left and as the water level drops it will allow you to fish all three sides of a cobble bar. Sand eels like to bury in the sandy areas between the cobble. There is a slight drop in the bowl to the north – many times the bass will be stationed on this lip so don’t end your retrieve too soon as the bass will hit just as your lifting your plug out of the water. Sometimes they station on the point of the outer edge of the bar and long casts are needed to reach them so get there early and try to position yourself with a shot at the point. Cast toward the light at Montauk on the left side of the bar – barely retrieve your Gibbs needle – don’t worry it won’t hang up because the pulling current will help keep it skimming the surface, just like a live Atlantic Needlefish. It’s very shallow on that side but the bass will all be pointed in your direction waiting for your needlefish. Strikes can be subtle – if you feel any weight – set! That is how to fish the bar with calm water and no sea. Now if you have a wind from the Northwest….”

You’ll never learn the entire “why question”. I know if I did I would have quit fishing long ago.

How's it going Rizzo!

DZ

Crafty Angler 01-05-2010 11:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pt.JudeJoe (Post 736823)
pointjudelurescatchfishpointjudelurescatchfishpoin tjudelurescatchfishpointjudelurescatchfishpointjud elurescatchfishpointjudelurescatchfishpointjudelur escatchfishpointjudelurescatchfishpointjudeluresca tchfishpointjudelurescatchfishpointjudelurescatchf ishpointjudelurescatchfish

AHA!!! Subliminal advertising!!!

...:laughs:...:laughs:...:laughs:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pete_G (Post 736827)

...But I didn't really care enough and couldn't fully decipher what was actually going on in the thread so a little humor thanks to the Iron Midget seemed more appropriate.

And probably one of the best from the Oracle of Anheiser, Pete...:hihi:

I remember a guy saying once it's just fishing, it's supposed to be fun...:kewl:

jeffthechef 01-05-2010 11:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Krispy (Post 736583)
Has created a commercial platform that gains from the continued sales of must have products, misinformation, flat out lies to keep its fishermen spending in their attempt achieve the successes of purported guides and mystic sharpie gurus?

wow. i used to agree with that 100%. but i always keep in mind though that as long as "fisherman" voluntarily want to spend money to "get better" or for "must have products" the "striper industry" will grow. a lot of guys make money on that fish via plugs, books, products, you name it...It blows my mind how so much that has been written lately is just echong what was written 30 or more years ago!
But that money goes into our economy one way or another, so really, the "striper industry" is indicative of of any consumer industry in the world. thats why some guy years ago said "let the buyer beware".

The Dad Fisherman 01-05-2010 11:44 AM

How about The Banjo Minnow....any thoughts on their productivity.....the Ads Guarantee Large :huh:

Clogston29 01-05-2010 11:57 AM

almost everything that you do in life is influenced by a commerical platform (to use your words). why would fishing be any different?

Nebe 01-05-2010 12:16 PM

http://fishki.net/picsw/122009/30/pi...dborka_068.jpg

rizzo 01-05-2010 12:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DZ (Post 736829)

You’ll never learn the entire “why question”. I know if I did I would have quit fishing long ago.

How's it going Rizzo!

DZ

Hey Dennis - its been a while too! Check your PM!

Krispy 01-05-2010 12:23 PM

Shoot, just wanted to get a winter topic going with a little controversy to get it started. 50 replies in 24 hours is pretty good :)
As many people posted, in the end the choices are ours as consumers who to buy from and to whom we listen to. Target large or enjoy a sunrise, to each his own. :gh:

Krispy 01-05-2010 12:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by redlite (Post 736729)
PAGE 2
Grenade+net= catch. PERIOD. Too many "+'s " in your equation. K.I.S.S. (my right arse cheek....its the lucky one)

Mike, every time you post you remind of one of my favorite songs:
What's Up Fat Lip!?
YouTube - FatLip - What's Up Fat Lip?

MAKAI 01-05-2010 12:39 PM

Man, my truck windows need a thorough cleaning.
I am SURE they need to be cleaned every day. . . it's not safe to be driving around with dirty windows,

TheSpecialist 01-05-2010 12:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CowHunter (Post 736740)
I love how many here are lost in yester-year and they dont even know what they have in front of them.....
- Give me pogies or give me eels
- Timing tide / wind
- Bite windows can last 15 minutes, .5hours, an hour, 1/4 tide, half tide, whole tide, multiple tides, slack tides, running tides
- The fish are always with or near the bait, those big bodies of fish, those that many dream of, are with sustainable bait supply
- Always go to the fish, the fish dont come to you.. Just because they were there last year, and the year before, doesnt mean they will be there now.
- Stay AWAY from the Crowds! All my biggest hits were done with not a soul in sight!
- Find your own grounds
- Pay attention to detail, the slightest things make a difference, the way you hook a bait, the weight, freshness, leader material, presentation....
- Stop chasing the reports and following others....Make your own reports - To yourself!
- Every day is a new day, learn something new...
- You cant buy experience on the bookshelves...Many want it easy - every day, they want the fish stacked. i got news for you, Gotta work for it...

This isnt yester-year, stop dreaming of then, this is now.... To many people are stuck in the past and dont change with the times, They Loose..........

John, I hear ya on the kids... I got 2- a 4 year old and a 2 year old and 2 full time jobs, fish smarter and make it count.... Ill sleep when I die...

Now, we can all be like sandman and bitch about how there are no fish...

2 hours in July of 09, 30 fish Limit

Bingo

agsurfr 01-05-2010 01:22 PM

well said!!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ivanputski (Post 736670)
as a fisherman, you should know that just because the bait is presented, doesn't mean the fish HAS to bite... Be the one that got away...

Well said!!

BasicPatrick 01-05-2010 05:53 PM

I absolutely hate it when i sit down at the puter and realaize I have no Popcorn!!!!!!!!

striperswiper75 01-05-2010 06:47 PM

I am relatively new to the whole surfcasting world; just finished what I would qualify as my second full year where I dedicated time and attention to the sport. Heck 3 years ago while on vacation at block for a week, I was fishing at night w/o waders, corkers, or a even a plug bag for that matter. I am kind of thankful for some of the resources that are available to me; some books, some fishing related forums and my fishing club in particular. Those resources really helped me get started.
At first I fell into the habit of buying tons of plugs I didn't know how to use, in tons of color variations. I also bought some rods and reels i don't use or need, but I hope my nieces and nephew will get use out of them. Through trial and error I think I have kind of figured out what I think works best for me (at the moment) and what I feel confident in using. I hope I have gotten past the point of needing to have XXXXXX lure and YYYYYY accessory; and will try to focus on what works for me and continue to learn from my few successes and many failures in the surf.

DZ, thanks for that SW point information, I finally got to fish it this past year, except I was there on the flood tide. Making a mental note on that one.

Kevin

JohnnyD 01-05-2010 11:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Dad Fisherman (Post 736842)
How about The Banjo Minnow....any thoughts on their productivity.....the Ads Guarantee Large :huh:

Ask the OTW staff. A couple months ago they whored out the "Lure of the Month" page for the Banjo Minnow.

The Dad Fisherman 01-06-2010 06:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JohnnyD (Post 736983)
Ask the OTW staff. A couple months ago they whored out the "Lure of the Month" page for the Banjo Minnow.


Did they really...Ouch.

DZ 01-06-2010 07:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by striperswiper75 (Post 736937)
DZ, thanks for that SW point information, I finally got to fish it this past year, except I was there on the flood tide. Making a mental note on that one.

Kevin

Kevin,
My pleasure. I'm sure there was some cut and paste activity with that paragraph. Those are optimum tides.... don't ignore the flood.

DZ

JohnnyD 01-06-2010 09:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Dad Fisherman (Post 736994)
Did they really...Ouch.

Yup. I can't imagine what they were thinking or how they expect to be taken seriously when it comes to product reviews.

After that, I'm now expecting at least a quarter-page review in 2010 on the Sham-wow and how useful it is when washing your boat.

fishbones 01-06-2010 09:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JohnnyD (Post 737024)
Yup. I can't imagine what they were thinking or how they expect to be taken seriously when it comes to product reviews.

After that, I'm now expecting at least a quarter-page review in 2010 on the Sham-wow and how useful it is when washing your boat.

There's a good size ad for the Banjo Minnow in the latest edition of OTW. Hey, they cater to freshwater fishing too, I guess.

Oh, and there was also a ShamWow booth at the RI Saltwater Sportsman show last spring.

redlite 01-06-2010 09:55 AM

I don't know why people knock the Banjo Minnow so badly. When I used to fresh water fish back in college, we used them all the time and they truly were amazing. They would out fish any other artificial we would use (rapalas, power bait, etc). Caught tons of large mouth bass on them.......and they have a kick arse tune that goes with them. I love the banjo minnow.

Clogston29 01-06-2010 10:12 AM

i agree with redlite. they're just as valid as any soft plastic jerk bait out there. the 7" mackeral looks like it would do pretty well in the salt to me.

BasicPatrick 01-06-2010 10:17 AM

Hey Krispy....Please :smash: pass the Garlic Salt

Raven 01-06-2010 10:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by redlite (Post 737045)
I don't know why people knock the Banjo Minnow so badly. When I used to fresh water fish back in college, we used them all the time and they truly were amazing. They would out fish any other artificial we would use (rapalas, power bait, etc). Caught tons of large mouth bass on them.......and they have a kick arse tune that goes with them. I love the banjo minnow.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
i'm not sure whats so special about them,,,,but

i was out in the boat on a reservoir in hopkinton and doing ok...
i am always lure hunting when i fish as a habit and noticed a soft plastic minow stuck in a bush....

i powered my way in there to get it just for fun....
it was a Banjo minnow...

i through it on my hook and checked out the action close to the boat just for the hell of it and a small bass slammed it.

so i proceeded to really fish the heck out of it and caught 45 more fish ... so i can highly attest to them working just as good as they say they do... and the only reason i quit catching fish on it was because by then it was shredded .....:uhuh:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:08 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Copyright 1998-20012 Striped-Bass.com