Haven't seen one yet that I disagree with, but maybe the criterion should be guys (and gals) who have made positive contributions to the sport whether they are well-known or otherwise, and not just make it for those who have passed on. There are people out there who deserve the accolades while they're still around to enjoy 'em.
Perhaps another idea would be to have people contribute short stories or anecdotes in an archive about the Hall of Famers as they remember them.
Excellent idea!
