Jenn,
Amazing what questions one will think of at 230 on a Saturday morning
I would have to say no matter what answer you provide, it will be "Wrong" in someone else's mind. If you want to keep a fish, keep a fish. If you want to keep every keeper you catch (and can live with yourself afterwards) then do so. I only keep what I am going to eat...and that is not much. Come to think of it.....I didn't keep a single fish this year. Oh well!