Had this happen many times. Combo's too. large bass on the belly treble and small blue on the tail end, two bass on a pencil popper, several times had two bluefish on same plug, two bass on one danny best was two bass on one eel. First fish ate it and somehow the eel got sucked right out through the gill plate opening when another grabbed the eel ang gotr stuck with the hook. Never forget that.
As for plug and teaser too many time s to recal but one night many years ago on Monomoy had two 30 pounders at the same time, one on the plug and one on the teaser and miraculously landed both. Had it happen many time before that but they always destroyed the rig and usually lost both teaser and plug as they battled each other.
It will happen again Eddy rest assured.
