View Single Post
Old 01-25-2011, 12:44 PM   #25
MAKAI
Too old to give a....
iTrader: (0)
 
MAKAI's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 2,505
Quote:
Originally Posted by 2na View Post
I use plate style because 1) I feel that it allows the blank to flex more completely 2) it gives better sensitivity, and 3) it makes the rod a little lighter. I feel that a collar style seat creates a stiff spot in the blank, just like a ferrule does. As Makai and I fish the same general area, the extra distance is important. And as Rizzo states, the sensitivity issue also factors into my choice - with your hand directly on the blank it transmits every little bump.

AS, I broke a collar style reel seat off of a factory St. Croix Ben Doer (sp?) a few years back. The seat itself didn't break, the epoxy under it holding to the blank let go. I've never had an actual seat come apart. I was happy it happened - the rod is much nicer with the plate style seat.
Btw
I broke that 9 ft st croix legend under load right at the ferule, didn't take long.
I'll stick with my customs. Those 20 yr old Arras still get the job done for me.

May fortune favor the foolish....
MAKAI is offline   Reply With Quote