Quote:
Originally Posted by spence
There is no Federal law stating your employer must give you a Porsche.
The Catholic Church wasn't ever asked to pay for anything.
First off, the analysis shows that the provision for contraception doesn't add to the total cost of coverage. The math is simple, a few hundred dollars in pills is a lot cheaper than several thousands for an unplanned pregnancy.
Second, in the compromise position (when Obama reached across the aisle) institutions with moral objections would have been afforded an exemption from the contraception provision...under the assumption the insurance provider could offer it directly and at no cost to the insured.
-spence
|
"There is no Federal law stating your employer must give you a Porsche."
Spence, you keep spinning in circles here, so let's make it simply clear.
Is there, or is there not, a law which compels employers to offer free contraception to employees?
"The Catholic Church wasn't ever asked to pay for anything"
They weren't? Spence, here you go making it up as you go along. That's what started all of this, Obama wanted the church to pay for contraception.
"the analysis shows that the provision for contraception doesn't add to the total cost of coverage. The math is simple, a few hundred dollars in pills is a lot cheaper than several thousands for an unplanned pregnancy."
That math may be simple, but it's also tragically flawed. First, if you assume that every single woman denied contraception has an unwanted pregnancy, then maybe it's cheaper to give her contraception. And maybe not, because are you sure an abortion costs more than a "few hundred dollars"?
Second, that analysis assumes that contraception reduces unwanted pregnancies. If that were true (and that's demonstrably false), why have there been so many more kids born out of wedlock AFTER contraception was made widely available?
Third, Catholics aren't concerned about dollars, we are concerned with that pesky First Amendment. you know, the one that liberals hold up to support the right of pornographers? Freedom of religion happens to be in there too.