Quote:
Originally Posted by spence
Government spending is part of GDP after all and programs to help the unemployed or poor do go right back into the economy.
-spence
|
But it's not the same effect as what happens in the free market.
Let's say i choose to buy a car. I choose to trade my money for the car, and the dealership agrees to trade the car for my money. Both parties enter the contract voluntarily, and thus both parties realize an economic benefit.
I don't know why you don't grasp this, but that's not what happens with government spending. In that case, my money gets involuntarily confiscated from me in the form of taxes, and I have little to no say in how it gets spent. Furthermore, in the current environment, the welfare programs may be doing as much harm as good, as they create a sense of entitlement that many poor folks get addicted to. They are therefore willing to not work, and collect welfare instead.
That does not represent wealth creation, it is wealth reduction.
We have 40 years of empirical evidence to see what happens when you throw money at the problem of poverty. Often, poor people are not poor because of a lack of money, they are poor because of behavioral issues. Those issues may not be solved, and indeed may be exacerbated, when you hand those people a check.