WOW this is a tough one......If I have to pick one, I would say Block Island is great!!!! We have gone up there for a week in the fall the last couple years. I love being out there the feel of the place, the fishing is good also
I hope to hit da vinyard some day. The outer beaches are nice also, we are skipping the week on BLock Island this year and doing a week on the outer cape.........Over all, all of my favorite stretch of bass water is from Watch Hill through Provincetown.......not real narow but it pretty mcyh sums it up for me