It's not entirely out of the realm of possibility by any means.
Especially in a few more weeks, I'd completely believe it. Water temps are over rated, if there's something to eat. Low 50's don't scare the little ones. I've said enough...
I heard rumors of Makerel at Jenny's and Ryan's horns. If they were there its possible that the tuna were as well. Its NOT too eraly for bluefins. There is sually a run of schoolies to the south of Block Island around this time of year. But right now there are tons of schoolies out in the canyons. I'd bet they will be inshore in another week or so.