Polaris VS Pencil

[partsjay]

Here's a question for you guys and girls.....Seeing as how I am a Popperholic...I love them, how I do alot of my fishing,....if you had to pick one, which would it be?....which one do you think would you think you had a better chance of going large on?.....what color?

I have done most of my damage over the years with polaris...green mack. I have one that has lots of MOJO on it.

[jeffsod]

Both are really good plugs each with their own applications. I never leave home without a polaris in my bag as it has taken many quality fish. The largest fish I can recall on a polaris though was 24lbs and my largest on a pencil was 36 &1/2lbs 48" from the canal.

[afterhours]

i can't pick one- both are great. being a topwater kinda guy i need to have both with me at all times. the polaris is great when i want to "call up" fish and the pencil is better at "seducing" them. favorite colors are yellows and whites.

[mike06512]

Gotta have both, but if I had to choose only 1 it would be the pencil, due to its versatility. You can work it frantically on top, walk-it side to side, slowly snake it through the water. It's also very aerodynamic to cut the wind..

[Rappin Mikey]

I wood have to say a pencil popper. My favorite is a yellow George Carlson.

[Nebe]

i'll take the popper. reason being i always have about 6 needles in my bag and i can cast them just as far as a pencil and I can work them in just the same way. but then agian i havne tused a popper once this year

[reelecstasy]

just one plug to fish with, probably would have to go with a pencil, no a popper, wait a pencil, eh fine, a popper

[ThrowingTimber]

Pencil as a search tool. Popper to zero in.

So yeah ummm half a dozen of both please

He who dies with the most plugs wins!!