Van Stall question

[ElSluggo]

Thinking of upgrading reel for wetsuiting and canal. Can't decide between VS200 or VS250. What's your opinion? Thanks in advance

[The Dad Fisherman]

How much line you want...thats the basic difference between the 2

[Thumper]

what size rod u putting her on?

[vanstaal]

[ElSluggo]

Don't have the rod yet either. Was thinking the VS200 but don't want to regret not getting the 250 after. May go with a rod I have now initially, probably 10ft m-h 3 to 6 oz range.

[RoyL]

i say all of the above aswell and what are you looking to fish on it. If your looking to jig the canal and sling eels I say a 250 might not be bad, if its plugging then I would go with a 200

[Thumper]

i dont fish the canal but with a rod with that rating i would say go with the 250, its only about 3oz heavier and has a nice retrive rate of 36.5in. i was just in ur spot and lucklie my fiance picked up a 250 for me and it matches great with my gsb1201m

[ElSluggo]

Thanks I'm leaning towards the VS 250.

[gone fishin]

Originally Posted by Thumper

i dont fish the canal but with a rod with that rating i would say go with the 250, its only about 3oz heavier and has a nice retrive rate of 36.5in. i was just in ur spot and lucklie my fiance picked up a 250 for me and it matches great with my gsb1201m

Marry that gal quick.

[ElSluggo]

Originally Posted by gone fishin

Marry that gal quick.

Don't you'll spoil a good thing

[titan]

FYI - the 250 only weighs 0.8 ounce more than the 200, according to the 2009 product catalog specs.

[chefchris401]

The reason for getting the 275 over the 300 was the price. I scored a brand new in box 275 for Don from AH, spooled with power pro for short money and he threw in a plug! Thanks again Don!

The reel is great, Ive been out practicing with it this winter and this month on the new rod, the retrieve is crazy fast but you can still slow crawl a danny or surfster.

found it easier to go slower with the 275 than faster with the 250, does that make sense?

[pmbrac]

Originally Posted by chefchris401

The reason for getting the 275 over the 300 was the price. I scored a brand new in box 275 for Don from AH, spooled with power pro for short money and he threw in a plug! Thanks again Don!

The reel is great, Ive been out practicing with it this winter and this month on the new rod, the retrieve is crazy fast but you can still slow crawl a danny or surfster.

found it easier to go slower with the 275 than faster with the 250, does that make sense?

Yeah, the 275 is sweet. I got one last year also used for real cheap but am going to put that on my pluggin rod and get a saltiga gt for jigging.. The gt is about the fastest reel you can get at over 50" per turn.. For all around beach fishing, the VS 200 would be my choice on a 9-10 ft. rod.

[ThrowingTimber]

Just my personal preference (casting style etc) but when I'm trying to go for maximum distance my vs just doesnt get it done for me.

I go to an emblem with the tall spool to get the most distance I can get (topwater/tin), rod is an xra1322. Jigging I go with an allstar 1208 with an abu 7000 series reel . In both of those cases Ive got no intention of swimming or dunking a reel.

If theres a remote chance(wetsuit) that I'm going to be wading deep, taking waves or swimming I go with my vs.

Again just personal preference but I'd rather jig with a conventional dropping back and adjusting depth is easier with one thumb movement (disengage pay out line thumb the spool, pay out line get where I want engage) opposed to physically taking the line off the roller getting to where you want to drop back to, then placing it back on the roller (crap missed a hit putting it back on the roller)

In the end both the reels you mention will get the job done period end of story. Its just going to be a case of what you find to be most comfortable for the way you cast/fish etc.