Looking for a versatile combo

[Uncle Matt]

Cowboy -

Where are you planning on fishing? What are you fishing for? Just stripers? Do you prefer spinning reels or conventionals? Let us know a little more information so we help direct you in the right direction. It may be tough to get you one all around "perfect" outfit to sling eels, heave chunk bait, throw poppers from the beach and be easily used in a boat.

[MotoXcowboy]

Originally Posted by Uncle Matt

Cowboy -

Where are you planning on fishing? What are you fishing for? Just stripers? Do you prefer spinning reels or conventionals? Let us know a little more information so we help direct you in the right direction. It may be tough to get you one all around "perfect" outfit to sling eels, heave chunk bait, throw poppers from the beach and be easily used in a boat.

Matt,
My friend's boat is docked deep in the EGreenwich cove. It's a little open type 20ft vessel with a 200 merc on it. I sit on a cooler as we ride out..We have just as much fun getting air on the way out as we do catchin fish. Anyway..We went out a lot last year mostly in the upper bay, and a few trips out to the bridges. We really wanted stripers, but mostly got schoolie bloos and fluke by the ton. This year, he's talking about rides out to the block on weekend and 4 dayer trips. I can't wait.

Growing up, I spent my summers in gansett and know the area pretty well. My buddy and I would drive our trucks down to my spots. I'm not gonna burn em, because they are popular enough, and we all know thats bad. so...lets get on to set-ups.

I used a hand-me-down pole that was about 7?8ft? tall maybe. It casted alright.. lets say in a dead wind I could thow an 1oz popper maybe 100-200ft with it. I dont know really. It had an old penn on it with a very small ratio. I didnt like it, to much spinning all day long. For line I used some 80# spiderwire because the guy at the bait shop told me it was "cool" so I got it. Little did I know this stuff frayed like a mofo near rocks! Lost a few good fish because of it. That pole later got destroyed by a big ol albie down on the wall. (I got him in with half a pole left on the last two eyelets, and then he ducked into the rocks and frayed my line! That fish kicked me and my poles arse!) Since, I didnt like the old penn's ratio I gave it to a friend who wanted to fixer up. After that, my uncle gave me a hand-me-down and its nice and all for a freebie, dont get me wrong... But, the ratio is the same as the old penn and the tip is REAL whippy. I am afraid of snapping it throwing heavy stuff! The line on it is pink the plastic kind (monofilament?)that stretches and I think its around 20# test.

So me and my friend would go down to the surf and throw casts with our Benny's type set-ups. We tried everything crab, dead shrimp, calamari strips, chunked macks, eels, worms, plugs, poppers, bucktails, kastmasters -ect. Our skunk ratio way to high..I dont know what we were doing wrong. All we caught last year were baby throwback stripers and more bloos. Oh yeah and many many skunked nights shared in the presence of good ol budwiesers..

I guess I prefer spinning reels although I havent used conventional other than while drifting on charter boats, or as extras for trolling in the buddy's boat. Even though it was a skunky year for us and striped bass it was still all good. good times.

That should be enough info for now. I just want a good all around combo that will be versatile and last me a few seasons. Sorry, Its easy to get lost typing while recovering from reconstructive heel surgery. But thats another dirt bike story, and Alton Brown (good eats) is doing a segment on cooking tuna as I type..

Lookin forward to getting some much needed advice.
thanks

[MotoXcowboy]

I thought about it more and figured, I can still use my hand-me-down on the boat. The girlfriend isnt going to be out with us that much. So, I'll use that on the boat and get myself a surfcasting rig this spring. What should I get? If you had 150-$250.00 to spend what would you get, Rod - Reel - Line?

Thanks

[Pete F.]

I'll jump in with my opinion.
Rod
Daiwa Sealine X 9 or 10 depending if you want to throw bombers or heavier plugs and bait
Tica 9 or 10'6" same deal
Reel Penn 704z slow is good fast might be the reason you are catching blues
Line 14# Fireline 300yds with mono backer
and this thread probably should get moved to the main forum

[rhodyflyguy]

OOOH! Pick Me! There's a 9"4" ben doerr spinner in the BST section, $100, get it! not mine, but sick rod! for a reel, get a Shimano 3500 BTR. They're bulletproof, and around $85. Spool up with 15# mono.
OR
If you'll be fishing mainly from a boat, and will be doing more trips to the island, get a rod to drift eels, an 8' rod with the same reel. monitor this board for a rod, you can usually get a custom that length for short cash, or pick up a Lamiglas Surf king 8', Tica 8', or St. croix Premier 8'. This combo will do double duty for you no problem.

[Slipknot]

I moved this to the main forum.

I'm not exactly sure what you need for a rod from shore or a rod for shore and boat, but that's not an easy one. If it has to be a rod for both, then I can't see it being more than 8' long. If you want a versitile surf rod, try a Batson 1088 or a Sabre 1088, that is a 9' rod and very good for a first custom rod. Rated 1-4 oz. When I first got mine I did everything with it form bombers to eels and even chunks.

[Fishpart]

Check the rod ZACS has listed in the classifieds. I have a St Croix 3S83M in a custom and and it is a nice general purpose rod and slightly underrated, so I can only assume that the 3S94M at 9'4" is a nice rod as well. I would recommend the Penn 704 or 706, ooooooooooooold rell technology, but they take a beating better than most.