The Bin Laden Card

[Jim in CT]

Originally Posted by RIROCKHOUND

I didn't say that they initiated, started whatever.
The fact is that War was declared by GWB, (and FDR). In terms of Japan (if I recall, Germany declared war on us first, we followed suit) and Afghanistan, they were 100% justified, provoked by an attack.

I see a clear distinction between those situations and Iraq.
that's all...

"I didn't say that they initiated, started whatever."

I must have somehting wrong with me, because that's twice this week I thought someone said somethiing (you and Spence) and maybe you didn't say it.

I asked this...

"Oh, Bush started the war in Afghanistan?
Do you think that FDR started the war with Japan in WWII? "

And you said this...

"Yes and Yes."

I also distinguish Afghanistan and WWII from Iraq. We were not attacked in a preemptive strike by Iraq, although they did fire at some American aircraft patrolling the no-fly zone, which could easily be called an act of war in my opinion. If my kid is flying that jet, I don't want his commander in chief giving a pass to some despot taking shots at him.

War was declared by Bush afetr we were attacked on 09/11 (and long aftre Al Queda declared war on us). Similarly, FDR declared war on Japan after Pearl Harbor (and aftre Japan declared war on us). If someone declares war on us and attacks us, and THEN we declare war on them and attack them, I don't see how you say we started that war.

[RIROCKHOUND]

Originally Posted by Jim in CT

I don't see how you say we started that war.

for #^&#^&#^&#^&s sake.

This all started because you took umbridge to JD saying Bush started two wars.

My final post and take on the matter.
Bush declared two wars during his term. One justified, one not.

[Jim in CT]

Originally Posted by RIROCKHOUND

for #^&#^&#^&#^&s sake.

This all started because you took umbridge to JD saying Bush started two wars.

My final post and take on the matter.
Bush declared two wars during his term. One justified, one not.

Bryan, I'm sorry. In my opinion, there is a huge difference between launching an unprovoked attack, and responding to an unprovoked attack that someone else inflicts upon you. It seemed to me you weren't distinguishing between those 2 scenarios.

I agree that Iraq wasn't as immediate an imminent threat as the Taliban.