21 pound lobster caught off Cape Cod

[Jim in CT]

It's a dinasaur! Anyone know how old that thing might be?

21-pound lobster caught off coast of Cape Cod; fate uncertain | The Sideshow - Yahoo! News

[Raider Ronnie]

My friend gets huge ones like that quite a bit on the Cape when scuba diving.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Slipknot]

got to be 60 or 70 years old

[Piscator]

gonna need a lot of butter

[robc22]

That lobster was caught in fed. waters.....It states that the chances of catching a yellow lobster is 1 in 30 million..I got a yellow one out the the ditch 2 years in a row......

[FishermanTim]

What I would be wondering would be:

How old can lobsters get, and at what age do they stop reproducing?
Just how "edible" would a lobster that big (or bigger) be? Wouldn't it be tougher, less flavorful than it's smaller brethren?
If that lobster proves to be less than perfect table fare due to its size and age, will they be returning it to the sea or putting it on display for as long as it lives in captivity?

Just curious, since we are so concerned with the keeping of large breeder bass, I figured that possible large breeder lobsters should warrent equal concern.

[MakoMike]

I used to get lobsters that big ir bigger all the time in RI. I think the biggest I got in RI was 23.5 pounds. There is an upper size limit on them now in federal waters.

[Piscator]

[QUOTE=FishermanTim;949935]Just how "edible" would a lobster that big (or bigger) be? Wouldn't it be tougher, less flavorful than it's smaller brethren?
QUOTE]

I know someone who ate a 9 LBS years ago, said it was gross........

[Piscator]

Originally Posted by FishermanTim

will they be returning it to the sea or putting it on display for as long as it lives in captivity?

Just curious, since we are so concerned with the keeping of large breeder bass, I figured that possible large breeder lobsters should warrent equal concern.

It was donated to the New England Aquarium

[Rob Rockcrawler]

I ate a 14 lber a few years back and it was great. The claw meat got a bit over cooked, only the tips though. The rest was as good as any lobster i have had. I didnt feel so good after dinner though. 2 sticks of butter has a tendency to do that.

[Green Light]

Wow. That's a lot of lobst'ah!

[MakoMike]

[QUOTE=Piscator;950186]

Originally Posted by FishermanTim

Just how "edible" would a lobster that big (or bigger) be? Wouldn't it be tougher, less flavorful than it's smaller brethren?
QUOTE]

I know someone who ate a 9 LBS years ago, said it was gross........

That's because they probably didn't know how to cook it. We've eaten plenty of 15 pound plus lobsters and they all were delicious. More meat in one 15 pounder than in 20 one pounders.

[Rockport24]

Originally Posted by robc22

That lobster was caught in fed. waters.....It states that the chances of catching a yellow lobster is 1 in 30 million..I got a yellow one out the the ditch 2 years in a row......

dude, you gotta play the lottery!

[Matt D]

[QUOTE=MakoMike;950287]

Originally Posted by Piscator

That's because they probably didn't know how to cook it. We've eaten plenty of 15 pound plus lobsters and they all were delicious. More meat in one 15 pounder than in 20 one pounders.

Most likely undercooked. Takes a lot longer to cook a big one, around 4 minutes a lb.

[robc22]

[QUOTE=Matt D;950358]

Originally Posted by MakoMike

Most likely undercooked. Takes a lot longer to cook a big one, around 4 minutes a lb.

+1

[Piscator]

[QUOTE=MakoMike;950287]

Originally Posted by Piscator

That's because they probably didn't know how to cook it. We've eaten plenty of 15 pound plus lobsters and they all were delicious. More meat in one 15 pounder than in 20 one pounders.

The guy that ate it was in Ohio. Might not have been “fresh” either. He said it tasted like iodine…………..

I'm sure there are not many palces in Ohio that know how to cook a 7lbs + lobster