Deja vu?

[DZ]

Interesting article from the Boston Globe 1977.

[Nebe]

Everyone should read that and do a little thinking. If you don't learn from history, you are doomed to repeat it!
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[piemma]

Dennis and Eben, no one is listening.

I have resigned myself to face a moratorium withing 3 to 5 years. I have been watching guys kill multiple 28" fish in the Providence River for the last 2 weeks.

The classic technique is what they call "snag and drop". Basically they snag a pogy and then just let it drop until a bass inhales the pogy and an 8/0 weighed snag hook. I have heard of guys snagging a bass, land it and keep it.

NO ONE IS LISTENING!!!!

[Sea Dangles]

Better late than never is what some with questionable common sense would say. Although I am no longer a subscriber, I picked up a copy of OTW at my barbershop yesterday. The editorial inside the front page echoed what DZs article just said in so many words. Yet, as far as I know they are still running a kill tournament, and the only reason conceivable must be da money.Sure ,there are bass available and still in large numbers if you are in the right spot,but the writing is on the wall. I talked to a friend in CT 2 days ago and asked him how the fishing was. He replied that he has not gotten a fish yet. This is not a guy who chases schoolies around with spinning gear, but he is an accomplished angler with many 50s over the rails. He has also won the OTW angler of the year from a boat multiple times and runs a charter business on the side. I suggested he look into fluke charters.

[piemma]

Originally Posted by Sea Dangles

Better late than never is what some with questionable common sense would say. Although I am no longer a subscriber, I picked up a copy of OTW at my barbershop yesterday. The editorial inside the front page echoed what DZs article just said in so many words. Yet, as far as I know they are still running a kill tournament, and the only reason conceivable must be da money.Sure ,there are bass available and still in large numbers if you are in the right spot,but the writing is on the wall. I talked to a friend in CT 2 days ago and asked him how the fishing was. He replied that he has not gotten a fish yet. This is not a guy who chases schoolies around with spinning gear, but he is an accomplished angler with many 50s over the rails. He has also won the OTW angler of the year from a boat multiple times and runs a charter business on the side. I suggested he look into fluke charters.

Chris, I agree with everything you stated. There are plenty of fish if you know where to look and how to fish. We have been getting our limit (4 fish) every trip. These are what I call keeper fish. My definition is 34" or more.

However, I have noticed that some of my "honey holes" are barren right now. Whether its water temp, bait, the cold spring or they just are not around anymore, I cannot say.

I'll have a better handle on the population in a couple of weeks. If my traditional holding spots don't light up, I will have to think that the general fish population is down.

The only bright spot I can relate is there was a worm hatch in Warwick Cove one day last week and there were millions of school fish on the worms.

[afterhours]

don't worry guys- the asmfc has a handle on it . they'll make changes soon......or in 1 year errh maybe 2 years or propose to form a committee in the future... we've been predicting this for a LONG time. and to otw- make it a total no kill tourney or iust stop it please.

[MAKAI]

For many years I could pick from multitudes of spots to fish shore or boat that I would feel confident about. The last few years those feel good spots have dwindled to a handful. Bait is at all of them. So relying on a beat to crap mother nature to replenish the greed of man is a fools errand at best.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Clammer]

GEEEEEEEEEEZ WE HAVE ONLY BEEN SAYING THIS FOR THE LAST 7- 8 YEARS ..

But even the ;[fisherman] on this && other sites ..............were calling it a Chicken Little ...The #^&#^&#^&#^&in sky is falling ...But what do we know

we only been fishing 50+ years , && have seen in in all phases ........

But the {FISHERMAN} that have been fishing for the last 10 -15 years .. wouldn,t listen ..they are catching we it must be ...the other guys can,t fish ........................... well the writing is past the wall ;;

I guesss seeing is believing >>>>>>>> If your eyes havnt been open by now .................. just put a #^&#^&#^&#^& - in hood over your head .................
you just don,t get it & never will ><><><><

[Rob Rockcrawler]

Wow, he really nailed it. Just change the dates in the article and it would be about today.

[snake slinger]

Things need to change and soon
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Got Stripers]

Said that we are about to put cars on the road that require no driver, which will take you where you want to go, while you sit back and relax; yet we can't figure out a way to protect what we have for the future. I remember so fondly fishing the milk run of ledges I'd frequent out of Scituate, where ever spot held dozens of nice fish and your rod was bent all morning until you were tired of catching. A slow day was 50 fish, with several nice keepers and I'm not fishing bait either, that was all light tackle plastic. I remember wondering what was happening as each trip suddenly was less and less productive, where in the end I'd have to work real hard in a morning for 15 fish and maybe one keeper.

It got to a point, where I opted to travel an hour further to launch in the Westport River and at least have the option to catch a few more and mix in some bottom feeders for the table. I miss the old milk run, but have really enjoyed learning new waters and targeting species I hadn't had an opportunity to fish for. Not to mention the beauty of the Islands, so even on a slow day, you are happy to be on the water.

Game Fish!

[FishermanTim]

Bring on the freshwater fish!

[bloocrab]

...really enjoyed learning new waters and targeting species I hadn't had an opportunity to fish for...

Like this nice fanged scup I caught earlier this week,
sure...one makes a rebound as the other one falls towards extinction......system is screwed up

fish on everyone!....while it lasts

[bart]

By far the worst start to a season EVER for me, and I think I've said that for the last 8 years now. Just keeps getting worse each season. Depressing at this point...

[Raven]

Originally Posted by Clammer

I guess seeing is believing

in my doc's office there was a sign that said
"if it's not documented it never happened"

and herein lie's the problem with "fish selfie's "
or you never caught it... jmo

and the crappy attitude that "all fishermen are liar's"

you cannot merely say you caught a 40 inch fish
your required to prove it....

[piemma]

Originally Posted by Raven

in my doc's office there was a sign that said
"if it's not documented it never happened"

and herein lie's the problem with "fish selfie's "
or you never caught it... jmo

and the crappy attitude that "all fishermen are liar's"

you cannot merely say you caught a 40 inch fish
your required to prove it....

Funny you should mention that. i was getting my balls busted last week because I didn't post a picture of the 23# fish I caught.
I just pointed out that I haven't been killing.

[chefchris401]

Originally Posted by FishermanTim

Bring on the freshwater fish!

this is what ive been doing lately, and its been a blast. freshwater is super relaxing and cheap, plus so much good water in NE, been hitting some nice fish too.

as far as striper fishing goes, my spring spots, which are usually lights out fishing by now in the east bay, have been the worst since i started keeping a log, 2004.

youll have one day of good fishing, but all the fish are small then 3-5 days of nothing, then one hot day and cold again

just look at the gotight scores and entries each week, youll see guys from up and down the coast, and the numbers are low.

im hoping its just a late late start, but every year it gets worse.

[Nebe]

Where's cow hunter to say we are all wrong?
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[vineyardblues]

Interesting read DZ
I remember lots more bluefish in the 70s
Right Clammer .....lol
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Clammer]

silence ><><

[MAKAI]

[QUOTE=Got Stripers. I remember so fondly fishing the milk run of ledges I'd frequent out of Scituate, where ever spot held dozens of nice fish and your rod was bent all morning until you were tired of catching.

I remember that bygone era well also. Best tasting bass I ever had was from those ledges. I swear it was because they were always stuffed with lobster. You could taste it in their flesh.
You are what you eat.
[size=1]Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device[/size]

[bassballer]

Originally Posted by Nebe

Where's cow hunter to say we are all wrong?
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Waiting to rake someone's name over the internet coals
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[numbskull]

I don't think the species is in trouble. The large YOY class from 2 years ago means there are significant fish in the pipeline to "sustain" a fishery.

What is happening is that since this YOY class will soon reach breeding age ASMFC has no reason to protect the remaining large fish. MakoMike would even argue that they are required by law to "utilize" these large fish and be sure they are caught and killed so as to satisfy the "Maximum Sustainable Yield" doctrine.

Since there have been a run of poor year classes most catch and kill fishing effort has been on large fish and that population is disappearing fast. This will only get worse because the ASMFC, driven by a predominance of members who favor continued maximal harvest (both recreational and commercial) over the quality of the recreational fishery, continues to take steps to perpetuate that harvest.

The mandate (and composition) of the ASMFC just does not serve the purposes of those who want a quality fishery (i.e., a widespread population distribution and large fish size). Striped bass management is a compromise and right now the interests of those who benefit from dead fish are prioritized over those who benefit from protecting live fish. Such interests are entrenched and unlikely to change. Once the large fish are gone they will lower size limits to allow harvest of the upcoming 2012YOY class.

[vineyardblues]

this is how the goverment has control of the surf guys

[Sea Flat]

Originally Posted by numbskull

I don't think the species is in trouble. The large YOY class from 2 years ago means there are significant fish in the pipeline to "sustain" a fishery.

What is happening is that since this YOY class will soon reach breeding age ASMFC has no reason to protect the remaining large fish. MakoMike would even argue that they are required by law to "utilize" these large fish and be sure they are caught and killed so as to satisfy the "Maximum Sustainable Yield" doctrine.

Since there have been a run of poor year classes most catch and kill fishing effort has been on large fish and that population is disappearing fast. This will only get worse because the ASMFC, driven by a predominance of members who favor continued maximal harvest (both recreational and commercial) over the quality of the recreational fishery, continues to take steps to perpetuate that harvest.

The mandate (and composition) of the ASMFC just does not serve the purposes of those who want a quality fishery (i.e., a widespread population distribution and large fish size). Striped bass management is a compromise and right now the interests of those who benefit from dead fish are prioritized over those who benefit from protecting live fish. Such interests are entrenched and unlikely to change. Once the large fish are gone they will lower size limits to allow harvest of the upcoming 2012YOY class.

You absolutely nailed this numbskull. That YOY class from two years ago was obviously a good thing for the fish and the future, but I fear it may have put a damper on any type of smart conservation tactics that may have been on the horizon.

[zimmy]

one good young of year isn't much to count on to sustain a viable fishery, especially given the health issues and water quality in the Chesapeake.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[afterhours]

has mycobacteriosis gone away? haven't heard much talk about it in a couple of years.

[Rob Rockcrawler]

I always read about the Chesapeake spawn, how big is the Hudson river spawn compared to the Chessy? Also, YOY analysis is for the Chessy right?

[wdmso]

Originally Posted by Rob Rockcrawler

Wow, he really nailed it. Just change the dates in the article and it would be about today.

and 37 years later we are still catching bass somethings worked.
but untill bass are removed from commercial fishing and return to a 1 fish (I like slot reg 32in-40in) at a federal level its kinda of pointless to ban the harvest here in MA if were the only state to do so

[JohnnySaxatilis]

Originally Posted by wdmso

and 37 years later we are still catching bass somethings worked.
but untill bass are removed from commercial fishing and return to a 1 fish (I like slot reg 32in-40in) at a federal level its kinda of pointless to ban the harvest here in MA if were the only state to do so

This seems like the biggest problem to me, each state has its own regulations, it needs to be an atlantic coast wide regulation system