Comm fishing grey area

[Justfishin']

I said during the last moratorium ( and I think the next one is coming) that I wouldn't keep another striper- and I like eating fish- as long as a working fisherman can feed his family, and I still mean it.

That doesn't extend to weekend warriors who managed to muscle in on getting a comm license to pay for a vacation fishing ,new trucks or boats. I'm glad to hear guys are getting busted.

[bobber]

good to hear theres some enforcement going on.....

how long does this crap have to go on?? theres a 25% reduction this year already- and (according to this thread) the prices are dropping...? why all the bullsh!t? I guess 15 fish a day can make you rich............

[thefishingfreak]

Originally Posted by Justfishin'

I said during the last moratorium ( and I think the next one is coming) that I wouldn't keep another striper- and I like eating fish- as long as a working fisherman can feed his family, and I still mean it.

That doesn't extend to weekend warriors who managed to muscle in on getting a comm license to pay for a vacation fishing ,new trucks or boats. I'm glad to hear guys are getting busted.

There is no muscling in, you just buy the permit, simple.
I do it because I like to kill stuff, the money is just a bonus
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Guppy]

Originally Posted by thefishingfreak

There is no muscling in, you just buy the permit, simple.
I do it because I like to kill stuff, the money is just a bonus
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Blood s#^&#^&#^&#^&#^&g com fishing guys are all alike ,,,

Anonymous

[ivanputski]

Fishing freak, you are only confirming what i already knew from your posts last year about the reg changes... You dont give a s*#% about Striped bass. Go kill some chipmunks in the yard with a bb gun and leave the bass alone.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[ecduzitgood]

Somebody's got to scoop up and eat released fish that go belly up. 8 or 9% of released fish die, that is roughly one in 12. I'm not fishing comercial so I don't have a dog in this fight but I do kill some bass...we all do if we put a hook in them.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[JohnR]

Originally Posted by ecduzitgood

Somebody's got to scoop up and eat released fish that go belly up. 8 or 9% of released fish die, that is roughly one in 12. I'm not fishing comercial so I don't have a dog in this fight but I do kill some bass...we all do if we put a hook in them.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Hi Ed!

[ecduzitgood]

Hi John and I haven't forgotten the plug it's just them damn sebiles took the wind out of my sails. They were what I was looking for and I knew i could do no better as far as effectiveness.
When i finish the jointed I will put it aside...it will be test swam..... well because you know...lol
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[thefishingfreak]

Originally Posted by ivanputski

Fishing freak, you are only confirming what i already knew from your posts last year about the reg changes... You dont give a s*#% about Striped bass. Go kill some chipmunks in the yard with a bb gun and leave the bass alone.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Wrong, I do care about the striped bass, I just have a totally different perspective then you and many more on here do.
It's my god given, government regulated and widely accepted right to harvest them in a way that generations before me have done and generations after me will do.
I do not kill mamals either, I am a fisherman not a hunter
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[nightfighter]

Wow. This thread has taken a turn for the worse..... So first, back to the original question. Yes, it does and has happened. More on that later.
Secondly, I am surprised at condescending, holier than thou tones I am getting from posts by some members that I respect.

Respect is the key word. I live far from the commercial hotspots, so don't have current dirt on who is traversing the no no lines with market fish. I can't believe anyone here would have the balls to "threaten" the OP for posting a question about this practice. Wish they would PM me, just so I know their character... There are different types of commercial fishermen. Those that work the big boats, and those that use rod and reel. Many of the latter are chest beaters. I have had run ins with both. I just don't care... And I am not going to be intimidated.

So it comes down to perception, if you are not actually there... I am not aligned with any side, so here is my take. FishingFreak would pass the muster test' ie. he does the right thing when no one is looking. Would you???? Raider Ron would too, I believe. (just have a difference of opinion on his verbal/typed expression/delivery style) They can find fish. They have made the investment in time and capital. They know and abide by the laws. That is my perception. They have my respect, as seamen and fishermen.

So back to the BI question. You would be naïve to think it didn't take place. The boat would have to be berthed in a port that would make economic sense, given fuel costs and lower daily maximum. Especially if other areas are giving up limits in an hour's time.

Comes down to being the man you dreamed you would be and doing the right thing when no one is looking.....

[Clammer]

Can,t we all be friends or at least respect each others choices ......... this is not helping the image of JR,s site

[bobber]

Originally Posted by nightfighter

Comes down to being the man you dreamed you would be and doing the right thing when no one is looking.....

theres some real truths right there.......

[MakoMike]

Originally Posted by thefishingfreak

The fin clipping rule totally eliminated this. Carry on
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

AFAIK there is no fin clipping rule in RI.

[Clammer]

I have to think that is completely being A/H,s REC,s catch them .clipped them & then they are safe from commercials pin hookers .........In MA .
That, kinda like the guys I saw Fluke fishing in RI that were putting a knife thru rec shorts & throwing them back in . so in their mind they were F U Cking the commercials guys

[zacs]

Originally Posted by Clammer

I have to think that is completely being A/H,s REC,s catch them .clipped them & then they are safe from commercials pin hookers .........In MA .
That, kinda like the guys I saw Fluke fishing in RI that were putting a knife thru rec shorts & throwing them back in . so in their mind they were F U Cking the commercials guys

anybody that does something like that should never be allowed to fish again. HOW STUPID!!!!!

[Raider Ronnie]

[QUOTE=nightfighter

So it comes down to perception, if you are not actually there... I am not aligned with any side, so here is my take. FishingFreak would pass the muster test' ie. he does the right thing when no one is looking. Would you???? Raider Ron would too, I believe. (just have a difference of opinion on his verbal/typed expression/delivery style) They can find fish. They have made the investment in time and capital. They know and abide by the laws. That is my perception. They have my respect, as seamen and fishermen.




If i'm reading/understanding this correctly you are paying me a compliment and stating I'm a smart ass.

If so, thank you :-)

[PRBuzz]

Originally Posted by nightfighter

Respect is the key word. I live far from the commercial hotspots, so don't have current dirt on who is traversing the no no lines with market fish. I can't believe anyone here would have the balls to "threaten" the OP for posting a question about this practice.

So it comes down to perception, if you are not actually there... I am not aligned with any side, so here is my take. FishingFreak would pass the muster test' ie. he does the right thing when no one is looking. Would you???? Raider Ron would too, I believe. They can find fish. They have made the investment in time and capital. They know and abide by the laws. That is my perception. They have my respect, as seamen and fishermen.

.....

I have rec fished with both (Fishbucket/Raider Nation) and comm fished with Fishbucket many times: don't dare take a short of any species or too many pounds/numbers of
fish on either boat!!!!!

You would have a hard time finding 2 better Capts!

[ivanputski]

Fishing freak may be a great captain and a great guy who really cares about bass..you just might have a hard time drawing the same conclusion from his internet comments sometimes... Thats all.
Guys who never met eachother in person that are members here have only the comments posted to use to form opinions about people, thats all.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Fly Rod]

I like everybody.......

Have never had the honor to meet FishingFreak,but from reading his articles and seeing photos he seems to be a damn good fisherman..... I find his views of fishing basically coincide with mine. Some people just do not like a winner and R jealous.


no matter what profession one is in there is always a rotten apple....there is an old saying..."laws R made to B broken."

[thefishingfreak]

As a member here since 2004 I refuse to let this place go down the tracks on the pitty train shoreatorium stripersforever trail to holiness and will pounce on any threads gone astray, preaching about how the greedy commercial black market bass fishermen and corrupt politician greasin charter boat operators are destroying the fishery because the fish aren't stupid enough to come inshore and attack pencil poppers on a day to day basis, with blunt force sarcasm and run on sentences of bad grammar and poor punctuation

[WESTPORTMAFIA]

Originally Posted by thefishingfreak

As a member here since 2004 I refuse to let this place go down the tracks on the pitty train shoreatorium stripersforever trail to holiness and will pounce on any threads gone astray, preaching about how the greedy commercial black market bass fishermen and corrupt politician greasin charter boat operators are destroying the fishery because the fish aren't stupid enough to come inshore and attack pencil poppers on a day to day basis, with blunt force sarcasm and run on sentences of bad grammar and poor punctuation

Amen! You need to get together with Trump.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[N.ShoreFisher]

Originally Posted by nightfighter

Wow. This thread has taken a turn for the worse..... So first, back to the original question. Yes, it does and has happened. More on that later.
Secondly, I am surprised at condescending, holier than thou tones I am getting from posts by some members that I respect.

Respect is the key word. I live far from the commercial hotspots, so don't have current dirt on who is traversing the no no lines with market fish. I can't believe anyone here would have the balls to "threaten" the OP for posting a question about this practice. Wish they would PM me, just so I know their character... There are different types of commercial fishermen. Those that work the big boats, and those that use rod and reel. Many of the latter are chest beaters. I have had run ins with both. I just don't care... And I am not going to be intimidated.

So it comes down to perception, if you are not actually there... I am not aligned with any side, so here is my take. FishingFreak would pass the muster test' ie. he does the right thing when no one is looking. Would you???? Raider Ron would too, I believe. (just have a difference of opinion on his verbal/typed expression/delivery style) They can find fish. They have made the investment in time and capital. They know and abide by the laws. That is my perception. They have my respect, as seamen and fishermen.

So back to the BI question. You would be naïve to think it didn't take place. The boat would have to be berthed in a port that would make economic sense, given fuel costs and lower daily maximum. Especially if other areas are giving up limits in an hour's time.

Comes down to being the man you dreamed you would be and doing the right thing when no one is looking.....

You're a class act Ross!

[Sea Dangles]

Lots of dumb people can catch fish, me included. The shortsighted knowitalls are under the impression that the stock is not in danger. The hypocrites don't think anybody should fish for them. What a hobby we have here.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Guppy]

Originally Posted by WESTPORTMAFIA

Amen! You need to get together with Trump.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

My guess is Mike doesn't golf, won't work