You are going to have to get a new side plate.
I live in Mass. But just about any good tackle shop should have all the parts you need.
Buko's in Fallriver isn't to far from the border?
But any who you can get parts and Schematic here at this site. Just click what reel you have and the parts will be listed. If you look above the reel pic you will see the link to a parts list and Schematic. This will help you pick the right part and part #
Good Luck!!
http://www.scottsbt.com/acb_sbt/cate...DID=8&catID=52