Here are some of my thoughts based on my own USAGE EXPERIENCE.
My choices are AquaSkinz, The Surfcaster, and BW Sports. I wish I could say something about the Canyon bags, but I don't have any first hand experience with them.
1) AquaSkinz. These are really well thought-out bags. You'll spend more, but these things look like they're built to last. So far, the ones I have are holding up very well to submersive conditions. Two basic plug bags to choose from - a full size one and a compact one that can be afixed to your wader belt (ideal for really wet conditions and long walks). If you get the small one, make sure you have a non-stretch wader belt for best results. These bags were definitely built by guys who know EXTREME SURF FISHING. So far, I think the AquaSkinz bags are the "IT" surf bag for the most demanding anglers. The only critique I have so far is about the small one - the drainage is a little slow and the plastic buckle takes a bit of getting used to if you're accustomed to velcro.
2) The Surfcaster. This is also a great CLASSIC plug bag, the standard to beat before AquaSkinz (and I guess Van Staal) came out. Three rows for plugs, inserts for bucktails and tins, side pouches for spare spools and leaders and terminal tackle, and a top flap pouch that will fit leaders and tape measure and maybe even a short rope. I think the Aquaskinz have an edge over this bag in at least two respects: the Surfcaster plastic inserts are fairly heavy (you'll notice the weight after a few hours) and the Surfcaster bags won't accommodate large wood.
3) BW Sports. This is for the guy on a budget. Definitely a nice bag that will hold big wood and pliers and the such. About 1/4 the price of what you'll pay for the higher-end offerings. The one I have is holding up nicely after one season, but I will say it isn't as durably constructed as the AquaSkinz and Surfcaster plug bags. Not a bad choice if it's your first plug bag and you're unsure about making the $$$ commitment to plugging. I wouldn't dunk it or bang it around on a rockpile - I think this is perfect for the sand flea who doesn't get all that wet.
Last edited by fishweewee; 05-16-2004 at 08:38 PM..
|