Rattling Plugs vs Non-Rattling

[basswipe]

I've done pretty well with Bombers over the years in particular the A-Salt version.Its probably a combo of the rattling and the action.
But nothing seems to beat good wood from what I've seen and especially heard from folks here.I've only been throwing wood the last couple of years and really only big time this year.
I must admit all my big plug fish have come on plastic body plugs that rattle like the Bomber.But I've also fished those types a lot longer.