cutting VMC's - Striper Talk Striped Bass Fishing, Surfcasting, Boating

piemma · 02-23-2006, 04:50 AM

had a bunch of cut Mustad 9510XXXS 6/0 Siwash fail a few years ago. Don't like the idea of a cut hook anymore. I believe split rings are the way to go.

Mike P · 02-23-2006, 10:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by piemma

had a bunch of cut Mustad 9510XXXS 6/0 Siwash fail a few years ago. Don't like the idea of a cut hook anymore. I believe split rings are the way to go.

The stainless Siwash are almost as bad as the cut Mustad trebles

Skitterpop · 02-23-2006, 10:56 AM

How bad on the Mustad Siwash 3X SS strong closed eye siwash?

Just getting ready to buy some for plastic/rubber rigging.

Thanks,
Another Knuckleheaded Mike

Mike P · 02-23-2006, 12:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Indanite

How bad on the Mustad Siwash 3X SS strong closed eye siwash?

Just getting ready to buy some for plastic/rubber rigging.

Thanks,
Another Knuckleheaded Mike

Dunno about the closed eye. The cut eyes are very brittle and snap easily.

I use the tinned Siwash by Mustad. But, they're old hooks and Mustad may have changed the metalurgy.

piemma · 02-23-2006, 12:29 PM

What Mike said.....

Skitterpop · 02-23-2006, 12:38 PM

I`ll post later this season as to how they hold up

lots of line on the reel and cafeful drag adjustment will be in the mix.

Fishpart · 02-24-2006, 10:32 AM

It's about the way metal is worked. To make a hook keep it's shape it needs to have a certain amount of "work hardening" or temper in it. In many cases the material is worked to a point during bending and forging probably gets the material close to it's ultimate strength. After you cut the hook, open it and close it again you are very close to going beyond the ultimate strength and the hook is subject to failure. Add to that the protective coating may be damaged in the process and you have corrosion sites that can further weaken the hook.

One bend you are OK, like Mike P says try to adjust it after it is closed and you take the metal beyond what it can handle and the eye fails. Smae thing with the SS siwash hooks.

After all that I still use open eyes......

chipwood · 02-24-2006, 02:10 PM

I use 3/0 or 4/0 open eye Mustads on all of my plugs without the split rings. The only plugs I keep the split rings on are my swimmers ( Cordells etc.) because I'm too lazy to take them off. I use the open eyes with the split rings too.I've never had a fish open an eye on me. I have had many fish bend and destroy trebles on me though. I just make sure that I check my hooks before every outing. Yes when the hook has rusted and it's time to replace, the open eye on the Mustad does break. But I never allow this to get that far because I am always replacing the trebles. I understand that plug builders use these split rings because if they ever had a fish open up an eye on a customer that would be the end of it. To me the split ring is just another step I don't need to go with.

jim sylvester · 03-02-2006, 09:24 PM

Pete,
was replacing hooks on some of my beachmasters tonight and with little effort the cut vmc's snapped

..after being changed in the fall and rinses withfreshwater on a regualr basis...makes you think when the fat lady comes along ifr the cuts will withstand her 50+ POUNDS OF STRENGTH
i know some plug builders such as beAchmaster swear by no split rings because it effects the action, but from what i saw tonight i will never go with cuts again....

JIM

ThrowingTimber · 03-02-2006, 09:54 PM

Zeno,

Opened the eye on a mustad open eyed hook last fall, was very pissed.. Never again no mustads for me.