MV vs Cutty

[Swimmer]

Vineyard access isn't much of a problem. No one has ever told me to leave, and I started fishing there in "73". Drive down every dirt road to the water I wanted. You run into anyone, look them in the eye and say hello! And keep freiking walking.

[Jim D]

i'm gonna have to go w/ cutty. Went over there twice this past september and it's just a great place. Went commando style on both nights and just fished from the time the ferry dropped us off till the time they picked us up. I think the longest we went with out somebody catching something was 20 minutes. Had fish to mid 30's that night and lost a few that were much larger. Would go back there any day of the week.

[baldwin]

MV has the luxury of being able to drive in a comfortable, heated vehicle to many diverse fishing locations. Inlets, sand bars, estuaries, rips, rocks,...
Cuttyhunk has rocks. Great structure, but much less diversity than MV. Also, you have to hoof it over rough terrain,...but I wouldn't trade it for anything. The island is set back in time, and recalibrates the soul like no other place. I've fished both, including about 14 trips to Cuttyhunk, and it'll always be one of my top all-time favorite places in the entire world.

[The Dad Fisherman]

Originally Posted by baldwin

recalibrates the soul like no other place.

Thats a great line....

[fishpoopoo]

Originally Posted by Swimmer

Vineyard access isn't much of a problem.

this is particularly true in the fall, and you can get wherever you want to with a bit of walking.

i've NEVER had a problem with access there.