Just a hypothetical question, Steve,...........for my part I'd go with a yellow/white medium danny. Good day or night most places and both big and small fish like 'em.
okay okay then my choice would be a needlefish, white. Something that comes easily to the surface.
chartreuse a-salt bomber even though it would limit the amount of conditions I could fish in. if i had to fish a whole season with one plug and used that I think I would still catch more fish by season's end on that than anything else.
no secret ,,,8" blue/white needle... Have a good history with that plug ... If you let me have 2 I'll take a 6" olive needle for spring ... again good history ..
Edit if I can have a third like others give me a 5 1/4" pearl white Jigman spook .. those 3 is all I need .