I agree with Z that geography has alot to do with peoples opinions. Im pretty limited to LI so 2 of the great ones would be
Billy the greek and Crazy Alberto. Most humble as well as successful would be Z.
I would think that until someone catches a 78lb 9 oz bass on rod&reel
Al McReynolds would be on the top of the list !
I'm pretty sure he (his son & daughter also) has quite a few 60s also !