NFL top 100 list

[BigFish]

Originally Posted by TheSpecialist

Brady should have been higher than Manning on superbowl wins alone. That list is skewed.

I don't worry about the placement of still active players......Manning is not as good as Brady in my mind! They are close but.....Brady has the edge....he has 3 rings! Higher winning percentage regular season and post season!

[Raider Ronnie]

Originally Posted by BigFish

I don't worry about the placement of still active players......Manning is not as good as Brady in my mind! They are close but.....Brady has the edge....he has 3 rings! Higher winning percentage regular season and post season!

2 completely different teams.

Pats are a complete team.
Colts are Manning and a handful of other guys.
Maybe they should have Vinatieri on that 100 list, he's got 4 rings and without him the Brady may not have 2 of those rings
Not knocking Brady , I think he's awesome (though his game seems to have really slipped the past 3 seasons) but he doesn't carry the team like Marring has had to his whole career.
Pats proved this with Brady out for a season and Cassel playing for the year.

[BigFish]

Complete team maybe but it is what it is Ronnie! Paint it with what ever brush you want! Brady has also had a greater influx of receivers to get used to....he hits more different receivers than Manning does, he has had different running backs and his defense has been in flux the past few seasons! Not to mention he plays his home games outdoors......come on Ronnie give the guy props.....even though he wears a Pats uni and you can't stand it!

[Raven]

he has a sprained ankle...

those are worse than fractures