Got a weber kettle that I have had for 5 + years still going strong, last fathers day the wife and son got me a kenmore, propane and charcoal, which works great, I still find myself using the charcoal. Gonna use the weber as a smoker now.
I went with the Weber because after a little research I found out the the fire box is aluminum and I was tired of cheap ones rusting out on me. I have been very happy with this grill.
Check out this thread from last year. Some great input.