Trolling rod for leadcore

[iamskippy]

Originally Posted by Sea Dangles

Skip, I'm not sure where you spend the majority of your summer BUT I am pretty sure that Paul and Jay have 100s of hours ;maybe thousands when combined trolling leadcore and wire, When they say it is just fine without a roller and you say it is a must who should we believe?Do you troll a lot of wire?BTW, I have roller tips on my wire setups but not on my leadcore.It doesn't really matter because I fish and they catch fish.

As a matter of fact i have over 10+ year experience with it. You can believe who you want its an open forum, but that will not stop me from giving my opinion, and please feel free to continue to call it out, as i only post base upon my own experience and tried and trued methods, not read on the internet or in a book like most people.

I also thought boards were open to discussions and opinions? Didnt the OP ask a question about feedback on the topic? So just because some members gave an answer is the end all? Perhaps we should post a resume with our experience and acconplishments? Maybe we can use a start rating system or fish tails to prove we know what we are tking about? Please advise........

Any other Questions?
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[fatcow]

Even the best of tips will get an indent from the wire. Its not necessary
but a roller tip works better with electric reels. Lead core will also indent
ur tips. Make sure u get good tips.

[beamie]

Skippy, ease your rudder.

By you saying it is a MUST and not preference is the problem here.

I prefer rollers, Dangles has rollers BUT there are MANY users of wire with non rollers and if you walk in a shop there will be a mix of rollers and non rollers for sale. Again preference, not a MUST.

I tried the non roller, hated it, changed it back. BUT, for some people, it doesn't bother. It is that simple.

[iamskippy]

Originally Posted by beamie

Skippy, ease your rudder.

By you saying it is a MUST and not preference is the problem here.

I prefer rollers, Dangles has rollers BUT there are MANY users of wire with non rollers and if you walk in a shop there will be a mix of rollers and non rollers for sale. Again preference, not a MUST.

I tried the non roller, hated it, changed it back. BUT, for some people, it doesn't bother. It is that simple.

How about this then, from my experience its a must for me.

So let me get this right and not to sound like a #^&#^&#^&#^& here, you all use it and hate not having one and due to the use of the word "must" as its a must for 99% of people, brash call out statements are going to be tossed out?

Lets take this a little further here, everyone should know that you can use anything on anything just about anytime its the effectiveness of what your doing, however this was a ask of opinions, and my opinion is its a must.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[big jay]

Originally Posted by iamskippy

How about this then, from my experience its a must for me.


Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

I think this is a fair statement.

In my opinion it's a matter of preference.

We keep 8 wire outfits on the boat - 6 do not have roller tips, 2 do. The 2 with them have been relegated to back up duty at this point. I personally haven't seen an appreciable difference in performance. I see the rollers as one more piece of maintenance, and with the number of days we spend on the water and the abuse the tackle takes - maintenance becomes a tangible factor.

I don't think we need to go all "online résumé" here, but I think it's safe to say I'm giving an opinion based on a significant sample size.

Most of the magazines and such will routinely state that roller tips are standard for wire - when I look around the other regular charter boats that we work with in cc bay, I'd say its 60/40 in favor of rollers vs standard.

To each his own - good luck to you this season.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Sea Dangles]

Originally Posted by iamskippy

As a matter of fact i have over 10+ year experience with it. You can believe who you want its an open forum, but that will not stop me from giving my opinion, and please feel free to continue to call it out, as i only post base upon my own experience and tried and trued methods, not read on the internet or in a book like most people.

I also thought boards were open to discussions and opinions? Didnt the OP ask a question about feedback on the topic? So just because some members gave an answer is the end all? Perhaps we should post a resume with our experience and acconplishments? Maybe we can use a start rating system or fish tails to prove we know what we are tking about? Please advise........

Any other Questions?
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Sorry if you took offense Skipper and I certainly feel opinions are what develops a discussion. However,if a charter captain gives an opinion on a subject he has a certain amount of credibility that can not be overlooked. I have been fishing the canal for over 10 years but I am no expert on anything canal related,it has no impact on my pocketbook,just fun. I have heard you are an accomplished computer geek and your expertise certainly carries weight(pun) in that forum. IMO describing a roller tip as a must was akin to insulting those who choose the alternative. 10 years is a long time in some circles but it doesn't cast a shadow in others.Don't forget that sometimes it is not what you say,but how you say it.

[iamskippy]

Originally Posted by Sea Dangles

I have heard you are an accomplished computer geek and your expertise certainly carries weight(pun)

Was that a fat joke?

[Sea Dangles]

Update;I just got off the phone with Charlie at CMS and asked him what % of wire line rods have roller tips vs conventional and he said he builds more with conventional. Small sample size again but in sharp contrast to your estimate of 99% roller.He just builds what fishermen want and I think he also has 10+ years experience...
PEACE

[iamskippy]

Originally Posted by Sea Dangles

Update;I just got off the phone with Charlie at CMS and asked him what % of wire line rods have roller tips vs conventional and he said he builds more with conventional. Small sample size again but in sharp contrast to your estimate of 99% roller.He just builds what fishermen want and I think he also has 10+ years experience...
PEACE

I have the up most respect for CMS, it will depend on who you speak to there as i have had rods built there, however you are correct with he will build whatever the customer wants especially if someone walks in that doesn't know what they want and the read something on the internet. Who is he to argue with the customer, however did you ask his opinion on having one or not? I would be curious to hear that response, because i have had that conversation down there and the response was roller for wire.

and 99% comment was in contrast to the people that i know.

[Sea Dangles]

Spoke with Charlie. He said it is mostly a regional thing with the cape guys wanting rollers and RI guys preferring conventional.He cited the failure rate with rollers with lines getting cut due to inexperience in most cases. He says he replaces a fair amount of roller tips that fail every year mostly from wire getting caught outside the roller. In conclusion,he didn't seem to think a roller is a must on wire rods.FWIW the majority of guys in that shop have been there for a long time and are short on BS.