I recommend Captain Mike Rehr, his website is
http://captflyrod.com/, he is on Sanibel and I have been fishing him since 1990 - he is awesome, and will catch fish when no one else does. He is primarily a fly fisherman, but also realizes that it's better to catch fish than stick only with the fly - he does what is necessary (but you also want to discuss that with him) ... one day we switched from fly rod to spin outfit back and forth catching one tarpon after another ... I was never without a fish from before the sun was up to late in the afternoon ... we have had epic, epic days of tarpon fishing ... amazing days of red fishing and beyond. He has a huge depth of knowledge and experience. If Mike is not available he can put you in touch with other guides that are worth the effort. His wife is phenomenal too ... one of the best.
Threaded Mode