A Season-Long Catch & Release Tourney

[Canalman]

Originally Posted by tysdad115

I sent Tylers waiver/consent form to you at info@gotight.net Dave. Is that where we send the forms?

Yes, I'll go put that on the site now, thanks for that--good catch!

[GregW]

Originally Posted by tysdad115

Anyone need a partner for this event? I'm going to put Tyler in the youth division but he wont be able to fish as often to compete . So I need a partner for the competition as Soups probably wont be fishing much this year. The good thing is it will be dark, so no one will see your with me.

If you end up needing a partner for this, let me know, I might sign up.

[tysdad115]

Originally Posted by GregW

If you end up needing a partner for this, let me know, I might sign up.

Sounds good Greg, if Slip isn't interested I'll let you know

[fatcow]

So guys that have commercial permits can't fish this tourney right? Sounds like a great tourney!!

[Diggin Jiggin]

Originally Posted by fatcow

So guys that have commercial permits can't fish this tourney right? Sounds like a great tourney!!

Why is that ? It sounds like you need to fish 6 or 8 weekends in this tourney. Most of the guys I know that comm fish are pretty much C&R guys the rest of the season and probably keep less than most of the guys I see on the canal. Comm season is what, 4 weeks long and they are knocked out of a season long tourney? Why not just not let em enter fish during comm season?

[Redsoxticket]

What is your take on those that enter the same fish in multiple tourneys.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Canalman]

Originally Posted by Redsoxticket

What is your take on those that enter the same fish in multiple tourneys.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Too hard to police that, I don't like it, but there'd be no way for me to know

[Canalman]

Originally Posted by Diggin Jiggin

Why is that ? It sounds like you need to fish 6 or 8 weekends in this tourney. Most of the guys I know that comm fish are pretty much C&R guys the rest of the season and probably keep less than most of the guys I see on the canal. Comm season is what, 4 weeks long and they are knocked out of a season long tourney? Why not just not let em enter fish during comm season?

That's a valid point and something I will think about.

My reasoning was if you've got a license and it's 34" it's dead.

But I will give some thought to your idea.

[numbskull]

I disagree.

These big fish are valuable and should be released regardless of their monetary value. Hopefully the people participating in the tournament share that philosophy and that, rather than fame, prizes, or reward is their primary reason to join.

[Chunkah]

I probably missed something, but under photo requirements you need two photos of each catch....what if you are entering, and fishing alone?
Thanks
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Canalman]

Originally Posted by Chunkah

I probably missed something, but under photo requirements you need two photos of each catch....what if you are entering, and fishing alone?
Thanks
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

You'll have to figure something out. Set the camera on timer or something. It doesn't have to be an award winning cover photo, but if I had it so you only had to take one pic, you could pass the tournament tags out to everyone on the beach and have them all shoot pics for you... know what I mean? I fish alone a lot, but I'd figure it out somehow.

Probably the best thing to do would be to figure out a good way to shoot the pic before you make a cast. Honestly, even if you held the fish against your body with one hand and held the camera out with your other so your face and some of the fish could be seen in the pic, it would qualify.

-Dave

[BatesBCheatin]

There should be an amendment that if a participant is seen with a dead fish over 40" during the whole season they are automatically disqualified from the tournament and are ineligible to win prizes.

Originally Posted by numbskull

I disagree.

These big fish are valuable and should be released regardless of their monetary value. Hopefully the people participating in the tournament share that philosophy and that, rather than fame, prizes, or reward is their primary reason to join.

[numbskull]

What you decide to legally kill and keep is your business but why would anyone want to keep a fish over 40"? That is too many meals from a single bass for a family to eat safely (if the fish happens to be a high toxin level fish then repeated meals from it creates high exposure).

[DZ]

Originally Posted by Canalman

That's a valid point and something I will think about.

My reasoning was if you've got a license and it's 34" it's dead.

But I will give some thought to your idea.

Stick to your guns Dave and keep this "recreational". You have a chance to start something truly unique. Once you include R&R Comm Lic holders it becomes a different ballgame.

DZ

[BatesBCheatin]

Originally Posted by numbskull

What you decide to legally kill and keep is your business but why would anyone want to keep a fish over 40"? That is too many meals from a single bass for a family to eat safely (if the fish happens to be a high toxin level fish then repeated meals from it creates high exposure).

They are generally not for one's family to eat. They are to show off on the backs of bikes, to friends, the internets, bait shops, and anyone else that will show them attention for their 'trophy'. Killing for braggers rights I think it's called. But we know that. Sorry getting off topic but not looking forward to the canal fish kills of May and June.

[tlapinski]

I absolutely love the idea of this tournament! I have my team mate penciled in, just need to work out the details.

I am all for you being able to participate as well, even keeping your eligibility to win prizes. The requirement of a photograph should eliminate any accusations of cheating.

[nightfighter]

Maybe the site should consider a forum dedicated to pics of released fish only.......as a way to promote the practice. Could certainly include pics from this tourney as well.

[Canalman]

Originally Posted by nightfighter

Maybe the site should consider a forum dedicated to pics of released fish only.......as a way to promote the practice. Could certainly include pics from this tourney as well.

Already in the works
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Canalman]

Originally Posted by DZ

Stick to your guns Dave and keep this "recreational". You have a chance to start something truly unique. Once you include R&R Comm Lic holders it becomes a different ballgame.

DZ

That's the decision I came to as well Dennis. But it was an angle worth considering. Ultimately, as you say, it's about promoting the benefits of C&R and fostering good practices. I have nothing against commercial anglers it's their legal right to do it, but in this tourney, it's all recs.

Thanks for presenting both sides of the argument guys!
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Canalman]

Originally Posted by tlapinski

I absolutely love the idea of this tournament! I have my team mate penciled in, just need to work out the details.

I am all for you being able to participate as well, even keeping your eligibility to win prizes. The requirement of a photograph should eliminate any accusations of cheating.

I appreciate that, but Im not going to take any prizes. It just seems wrong. But Team GoTight will be competing.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[piemma]

Originally Posted by BatesBCheatin

There should be an amendment that if a participant is seen with a dead fish over 40" during the whole season they are automatically disqualified from the tournament and are ineligible to win prizes.

I hope this is a "tongue in cheek" comment because if it isn't, I disagree wholeheartedly. It's your business if you want to kill a fish over 40". I'm not advocating it but it's your god given right to keep whatever you want providing you are within the law.

[Canalman]

And Bruce, to answer your question about dead bait, if I made it sound like their use is illegal in the rules I made a mistake. I'll review the wording today. Any lure or legal live or dead bait is okay.

Sorry for the confusion
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Redsoxticket]

There should be no pics display because the background such as rocks, sand and water can reveal the location. There should be a non participant of the tourney that is honest, tight lipped and able to gather the pics and data sent to him or her via a pm with a pic upload. In my opinion Canalman Dave would suit this position or a designated nominee with similar attributes.

[Canalman]

Originally Posted by piemma

I hope this is a "tongue in cheek" comment because if it isn't, I disagree wholeheartedly. It's your business if you want to kill a fish over 40". I'm not advocating is but it's your god given right to keep whatever you want providing you are within the law.

I think he was joshing Paul, and don't worry, that will not become a rule. I don't want to remove anyone's right to keep something for food or a trophy.. What I DO want is to make it possible to enter any fish without killing it and not to give people a reason to kill a big fish when they otherwise would have let her swim.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[piemma]

Originally Posted by Canalman

I think he was joshing Paul, and don't worry, that will not become a rule. I don't want to remove anyone's right to keep something for food or a trophy.. What I DO want is to make it possible to enter any fish without killing it and not to give people a reason to kill a big fish when they otherwise would have let her swim.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Agree with all you have stated Dave. I'm in and will help support in any way I can

[Canalman]

Originally Posted by Redsoxticket

There should be no pics display because the background such as rocks, sand and water can reveal the location. There should be a non participant of the tourney that is honest, tight lipped and able to gather the pics and data sent to him or her via a pm with a pic upload. In my opinion Canalman Dave would suit this position or a designated nominee with similar attributes.

Not going to happen. Part of the fun of this kind of thing is seeing what everyone else has caught. When I shoot pics I just make sure there are no obvious landmarks in the background. It's your responsibility to protect your spots. But the photos have to be made public for this to work.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Canalman]

Originally Posted by piemma

Agree with all you have stated Dave. I'm in and will help support in any way I can

Thanks Paul
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Redsoxticket]

Originally Posted by Canalman

Not going to happen. Part of the fun of this kind of thing is seeing what everyone else has caught. When I shoot pics I just make sure there are no obvious landmarks in the background. It's your responsibility to protect your spots. But the photos have to be made public for this to work.
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

Great idea about removing obvious landmarks, problem solved

[Chunkah]

Originally Posted by Canalman

You'll have to figure something out. Set the camera on timer or something. It doesn't have to be an award winning cover photo, but if I had it so you only had to take one pic, you could pass the tournament tags out to everyone on the beach and have them all shoot pics for you... know what I mean? I fish alone a lot, but I'd figure it out somehow.

Probably the best thing to do would be to figure out a good way to shoot the pic before you make a cast. Honestly, even if you held the fish against your body with one hand and held the camera out with your other so your face and some of the fish could be seen in the pic, it would qualify.

-Dave

Sounds extremely reasonable....thanks!
Posted from my iPhone/Mobile device

[Sundowner]

"Good on ya" Dave and John