Capt Bob Rochetta vs Albert McReynolds

[BassDawg]

So, I'm thumbing thru Oct's SWS and on the last page I come across this one pager by Capt Bob Rochetta, and it gets me to thinking...............................

In my view, even though the IGFA recognizes the McReynolds 78.6#er as its current World Record for Striped Bass, I find it difficult to accept/lend credence to a striper that was landed by "two" people. By Mr McReynolds' own account (avail. on line via Google, "On the Run") he was under tackled (20# test w/no shock leader) and at that fatefeul moment when he decides to swim with his monstah, since he was not going to win the fight by gear alone, his buddy gives Albert an unfair advantage by adding the second man to the battle.

Had McReynolds been able to swim with her and land her on his own, then we have an incredible and amazing feat worthy of acclaim and Record Books. But, without the aid of his partner I am certain that the fish would have won the fight that Nor'easter laiden night. Clearly, his tackle was insufficient to do so.

Am curious as to where the most of us stand? There is no right or wrong, just whether one agrees or disagrees with the legitimacy of the McReynolds fish. And if one does disagree, then Capt Bob becomes the Highest Hook, yes? Ah but his Striper came from a boat, quite the dilemma. And the stuff that winter pondering is made of....................

Just trying to pass the time before kick-off while the weather continues in its "delightfulness". What say you, gents?