Are you holding out?

[Goose]

I'm not referring to spots but anything and everything else. This site is loaded with awsome info as we all know and share but is there something that you do, have rigged ect. ect. that you will not spill? A simple yes or no will do.

I know there's a handfull of guys that will go to their graves with what they consider "the anglers edge".... and i also know that theres a handfull who think we're @holes.

[Clammer]

YEP -but I,ve been trying to decide if I,m gonna give it up -------I can,t pass it along to my son ========== he never got this addiction

[Slipknot]

no

Originally Posted by Goose

and i also know that theres a handfull who think we're @holes.

"we're"? that means you are one of the holdouts? if you are that is not such a bad thing and I don't blame you. But I would think that before one goes off to that great cuttyhunk in the sky, they'd try to pass on some of those secrets since I bet alot was passed on to them also thru the years.
or maybe I don't know what I'm talking about.
I just like the way when I speak to a guy like Stan Kuzia, that he will tell you lots in a conversation, he's not holding back I don't think. I respect that.

[Squid kids Dad]

Slip.My thoughts exactly...

[bluzjamer]

Gas prices are killing the old scoutem out routine. I've caught lots of schoolies through the years but I can count the keepers on one hand. Only 1 30# fish. I would love to bag one for the grill. Just haven't been to lucky or fish too much with the fly stick. I still haven't hit my first schoolie yet for this year. I gone out about 6-8 times. My tried and true spots aren't working and gas is keeping me from exploring. I think it's going to be a tough year.

[Clammer]

B/J sounds like ya watching the tube ===tooooooooo Much

[fishaholic18]

Nope, I don't hold out, I always put out...

Hi Tony..

[GBOUTDOORS]

Tony I have told you everything I know and still you know nothing The only thing I know is if you fish they will come

[seabass]

I tell you my secret, my son can speak morone saxatallis!

[JFigliuolo]

Put me in the second group... To people I have fished with on more than one occasion, I am an open book. The downside of that, is I am more like a leaflet, than a book per say.

[lurch]

Originally Posted by seabass

I tell you my secret, my son can speak morone saxatallis!

Just like harry potter speaking parsel tounge.

It is amazing how much a person knows about fishing but may not realize that they know it.

[Nebe]

Originally Posted by Clammer

YEP -but I,ve been trying to decide if I,m gonna give it up -------I can,t pass it along to my son ========== he never got this addiction

im open ears papa

[Goose]

Doesn't anyone take off their producing lure as they walking the surf or is that just in books? You take car racing for example: they'll keep a tiny secret secret because it took year$ for them to drop one second or even 1/2 a second, fishing isn't any different. I say 99.9 of everything I know but if I'm asked to stay hush then I'm only as good as my word.

[tattoobob]

I am sorry I don't like to brag or tell tails, I have also been known to lose fish because I dropped my rod when another beach buggy drives by. I don't like crowds and lose lips sinks ships. if I come to fish a spot and there are alot of others fishing I go find another.

[Clammer]

This [[IS]] a F #$%^&*(0 disease ::;;

TONY // ya got me thinkin =no worries it won,t last long ><>><><

Years ago there were a select few of us that targeted a certain species of fish ----- commercially -- ATT I was the youngest /// we didn,t [really] fish with each other ==but we all fished 95% of the same places =============&& sold to the same market ...

Well one night we did a all nighter & into the mid morning ==================== when we stopped at a tackle shop we found out that one of the guys was hit in the head with a hammer walking home that night & died

First F #$%^&*( thing that came to my head WAS ================ one less guy to F #%^7 with & as he goes so does his knowledge =======

there I,ve said what many have thought at one time or another ========= ya I know f #$%^&*( sick

[ThrowingTimber]

Originally Posted by Clammer

YEP -but I,ve been trying to decide if I,m gonna give it up -------I can,t pass it along to my son ========== he never got this addiction

I take notes everytime bud

[Clammer]

t/t BuT YA ONLY CAN RIGHT DOWN WHAT YA SEE OR HEAR

[piemma]

Yeah, I give up everything. You can all follow me around. Red International Scout RI plate number RT 590.

[JohnR]

I don't know - I think it is balance. Some things given to you in confidence should stay in confidence, some info you have earned through doing don't necessarily spill all the beans but give out a drible and a dabble. Paraphrasing a little here but some say that the journey to gain the knowledge can often BE the knowledge. If someone shows / tells me something it doesn't mean that I know it. I still need to learn it...

So from another angle, if you KNOW something and it is really good, what's better? To give the knowledge in one fell swoop? Or to give bits and pieces and guide someone until they LEARN it? I have found that the few things that have penetrated my skull are clearer and sharper when I have learned on my own or someone guided my thinking rather than someone saying go here and cast there... This knowledge might shorten the learning curve a bit but it does not elimiate the learning curve. It still must be learned...

[hulkyj61]

I can't say I would post a spot online for all to see, but if I get talking to someone who knows the area I may spill a little. Also there are very few "secret" spots left these days, but there are a few, and some are obvious fishing spots (breakwaters, river outflows, rocky coves) that people are automatically always going to go to.

[stiff tip]

yes some things u keep to your self......but the older you get the lips get looser ...then 1 day u realize wtf what good does it in the grave..thats when u pass it along to your -buds-

[EricM]

I am happy to share what little knowledge I have gained through my own personal time on the water.

What I have learned from personal discussions with others regarding what THEY learned from time on the water, however, I keep to myself, as it is their "lessons learned" and not mine. It is the result of their work, time, and experimentation, and therefore it is their choice what to do with it.

[eelman]

yes, definatly.. Just cannot trust people been let down far to many times..Its why I dont fish with many people..Most of the time I like to be alone.But I will share info freely with a couple people, they know who they are.I may let out 99% of what I do with an eel...but there is that 1% I keep all to myself and always will.....

[NIB]

I have seen it happen when Old Salts I know who wouldn't give ya the time of day yrs.ago All of the sudden have a change of heart an are willing to spew to whoever will have their ear..
When it comes down to it.It's still just common sense.
It's all the little nuances u can read about em in some books or magazines,or have someone tell ya.
Till u experience them for urself though it won't click in.
Time on the water is the real secret..
That said i share some an keep the real jewels to myself..

[fcap60]

yes

[BW from AZ]

Originally Posted by JFigliuolo

Put me in the second group... To people I have fished with on more than one occasion, I am an open book. The downside of that, is I am more like a leaflet, than a book per say.

same here except i"m more like a sticky post it. i"m still learning

[Raven]

full of secrets...

the area 51 of striped bass fishing....

heh heh heh.....

[numbskull]

I got a lot of secrets.....but I can't remember where I put 'em.

[Tagger]

When people fished for a living or survival ,from shore it was all about secrets . Cup the lure your using in your hand so no one can see and stop fishing and leave .. I like most rec guys share ,,, If I had to survive by my fishing things would be different .

[pal156]

i pass on most of my info must keep a few tactics in the attic