Has anyone surf fished um? I know there are huge signs that state "Private property ' No trespassing ' Violators will be prosecuted ' etc.ect.. Its not that I don't respect private property...

Hi Forbes...but dam we're talkin bout many miles of shoreline most of which is prime fishing waters. I doubt Mr. Forbes or his care taker is walkin the rock gardens at 1am.
The other islands have imo better stretches then cutty(surf friendly). The biggest obstacle who be to safe and secure area to get in and out, which can be done.
So, any you surf boaters break that law? I know for fact that some have.