Will probably end up trying all of those. Thanks guys, hopefully I can post some pictures tomorrow if I have some luck. If anyone else is heading out, come meet me out there. Look for the rocks!
Try a cedar plug (color: black) with a single feathered hook tied with saddle hackle (color: black) or a cedar plug (color: black) with a single 6/0 bare hook on which you've threaded a 4-inch Slug-Go or a 4-inch Senko Worm (color: black). Cedar plugs with feathered hooks outfish most soft plastics lures and black cedar plugs with black trailers outfish even black 9-inch Slug-Go's.