Jim Rice

[striperking70]

Originally Posted by BigFish

Again with the winning?? Is that what you believe a HOF'er is??? They are elected based on their individual career numbers and performance....not whether they won a championship or not! Nolan Ryan never won a championship.....I think we should rescind his HOF status! Oh sorry.....Ryan did win one...as a member of the 69 Mets....I think he was waterboy or something!

Your going to compare Rice to Nolan Ryan

[wrikerjr]

Jim Rice does not belong in the same sentence as:

- Mickey Mantle
- Ted Williams
- Ernie Banks

period. full stop. end of story

if your a winner, that helps you get into the hall of fame. regardless of its correct or not.